In this, our first two-part episode on The Grading Podcast, Sharona and Bosley speak with Dr. Jeff Anderson, a community college math professor who has been thinking and writing about alternative assessment practices since at least March 2021. This interview was so interesting and nuanced we just couldn’t fit it into a single hour! Join us for a in-depth personal and professional journey about the impact grades had personally on Jeff and how he utilizes his lived experience to work towards a more just educational system and changes to our grading practices.
Links
Please note – any books linked here are likely Amazon Associates links. Clicking on them and purchasing through them helps support the show. Thanks for your support!
- What is Good Mathematics? Terence Tao
- The Harmful Worldviews that Undergird the Letter Grading System, blog post by Dr. Jeff Anderson
- A Century of Grading Research: Meaning and Value in the Most Common Education Measure, Brookhart, et. al
- The Happiness Lab: Making the Grade, podcast episode
- Stamped from the Beginning: The Definitive History of Racist Ideas in America by Ibram Kendi
- Punished by Rewards by Alfie Kohn
- The Big Myth: How American Business Taught Us to Loathe Government and Love the Free Market by Naomi Oreskes
- Drive: The Surprising Truth About What Motivates Us by Daniel Pink
Resources
The Grading Conference – an annual, online conference exploring Alternative Grading in Higher Education & K-12.
Some great resources to educate yourself about Alternative Grading:
Recommended Books on Alternative Grading (Please note – any books linked here are likely Amazon Associates links. Purchasing through them helps support the show. Thanks for your support!):
- Grading for Growth, by Robert Talbert and David Clark
- Specifications Grading, by Linda Nilsen
- Undoing the Grade, by Jesse Stommel
- Grading for Equity, by Joe Feldman
The Grading Podcast publishes every week on Tuesday at 4 AM Pacific time, so be sure to subscribe and get notified of each new episode. You can follow us on Twitter, Facebook and Instagram – @thegradingpod. To leave us a comment, please go to our website: http://www.thegradingpod.com and leave a comment on this episode’s page.
If you would like to be considered to be a guest on this show, please reach out using the Contact Us form on our website, www.thegradingpod.com.
All content of this podcast and website are solely the opinions of the hosts and guests and do not necessarily represent the views of California State University Los Angeles or the Los Angeles Unified School District.
Music
Country Rock performed by Lite Saturation
Country Rock by Lite Saturation is licensed under a Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.
Transcript
55 – Anderson part 1
===
Boz: Here on The Grading Podcast, we sat down with Dr. Jeff Anderson. However, this interview ended up being so entertaining and so educational that we could not complete it in a single hour. So join us as we start part one of our first two part episode here on The Grading Podcast. Hope you enjoy and return next week for part two. Welcome to The Grading Podcast, where we’ll take a critical lens to the methods of assessing students learning. From traditional grading to meth alternative methods of grading. We’ll look at how grades impact our classrooms and our students success. I’m Robert Bosley, a high school math teacher, instructional coach, intervention specialist, and instructional designer in the Los Angeles Unified School District and with Cal State LA.
Sharona: And I’m Sharona Krinsky, a math instructor at Cal State Los Angeles, faculty coach, and instructional designer. Whether you work in higher ed or K 12, whatever your discipline is, whether you are a teacher, a coach, or an administrator, this podcast is for you. Each week you will get the practical, detailed information you need to be able to actually implement effective grading practices in your class and at your institution.
Boz: Hello and welcome back to the podcast. I’m Robert Bosley, one of your two co hosts, and with me as always Sharona Krinsky. How are you doing today, Sharona?
Sharona: You know, we, at the time of this recording, are getting very close to this year’s grading conference. So, I’m feeling a little bit immersed in a very good way in grading, and in those kinds of things, and a little bit nervous. We have our largest ever conference this year. So I’m excited and a little, little bit like, Oh my gosh, I can’t believe we’re on year five. How about you?
Boz: Yeah, I’m about the same, you know at the time we recorded now by the time this comes out, the conference would have been over for a little while, but yeah, it’s, It’s exhilarating and a little bit nervous with just how much larger I got this year than it has in the past. So hopefully, hopefully everything goes well.
Sharona: So, and then we do have a guest in studio today someone new to us on the pod. I’d like to introduce Dr. Jeff Anderson. Welcome Jeff to the virtual recording studio. So Jeff is a math professor at Foothill community college. And his top level professional goal, to use his own words, is to use anti racist learning science to help people thrive. He hopes to empower people in his life to leverage their own sense of democratic engagement in our communities, and to think deeply about how they might use their learning skills as tools to serve and empower other people.
I think what I love about this introduction is this is not what you would typically hear from a math professor. Like, you know, I could kind of understand somebody in English or communication or one of the anti racist, critical race theory scientists, but this is coming from a mathematician who, and again Dr. Anderson or Jeff teaches a variety of lower division undergraduate classes linear algebra, MATLAB, and calculus. He also works as a research educator, resource mathematician, and an educational consultant. As well as an author, a content creator, a learning skills mentor, and a scholarship coach. And I believe I heard you are a parent. So welcome to the podcast of the vastly overworked, overcommitted. But welcome. I think, Bosley, we might have met our match here.
Dr. Anderson: I feel so blessed to be in this space.
Sharona: You are welcome.
Boz: One of the things that we always like to ask our new guest is your origin story into this crazy world of alternative grading. Like how did you get involved with this?
Dr. Anderson: I love it. I might respond back with by demonstrating live in action. One of the practices I use in my class, which is choice. One of the ways that I fight behaviorism is by encouraging students to make choices. So, I would ask you back, would you like the beginning level, intermediate level or advanced level response to this question? Beginning level is faster, but with less depth and detail. So it leaves a little bit remained unsaid. Advanced level is a little bit longer, but it gives a lot more detail and clarity into the kind of the story that led to some of the decisions that I make, which I hope that we discuss later in the podcast and I leave it up to you.
Boz: I definitely want to hear some of the details. So let’s go for the intermediate level.
Sharona: Oh, no, I’m going, I’m voting advanced Boz. I think our audience can handle it. And if you’re listening to the podcast now, yes, I’m pushing for advanced. Do you agree, Boz?
Boz: All right, let’s go. Let’s go with the whole shebang.
Dr. Anderson: Awesome. All right. So I guess in that situation, how fun, I would break it into two different parts. One of them is a personal story. Another one is a professional story. I think one of the practices that’s so important in the process of healing, I call alternative assessment, a healing process for each of us, because many of us survived 20 plus years in the education system. And then we got our first jobs without, you know, in order to get my job, I needed zero classes in education theory, assessment theory, and anti racism. And then I’m in front of the room with 200 students. And so in the absence of training, I rely back on what I call the apprenticeships of observation.
So, so much of grading work in my life has been the process of healing from my own experiences in school and then freedom dreaming or imagining something new. So in this moment, I’m going to first talk a little bit about the healing process, which is a personal story. And then I’ll transition into how that personal story relates to the professional growth that I went on to get to the place where I am now. So the healing story really is grounded in sixth grade. The first quarter of sixth grade was the first quarter that I ever received letter grade. So from K through five was all One, twos, and threes. One meant not yet there, two meant on the way, three meant something like this. So my first quarter of sixth grade, I had seven classes, three of which were with my homeroom teacher. And I remember we received grades in probably November of that year. So we started in August, went to November. And I got four A’s, except with my homeroom teacher, who taught three classes. I won’t say her name, but I got a B+, a B-, and a C+ and I remember that that was the first day I learned what grades were and that we’re even being graded. And we were at the conference and I remember asking, I don’t even remember you talking about the fact that I was missing anything. And she said something that I never forgot, which was, it’s not my job to tell you what your progress is. It’s your job to come find me and ask me about it.
Yeah, so that moment was a really pivotal moment because from that moment forward, I saw her every single week. And not only did I see her every week, I saw every other teacher that I worked with every single week. From the sixth grade until the end of college, I received nothing less than an A. And I can map it back to that moment, actually, like literally every single grade. I got an A- in three classes in college. I have some stories about that in a minute, but when I go back to that teacher, she taught me two things. Number one, how arbitrary grading was, and how it very much depended on the teacher. And if we’re serious about understanding the game of grades of students, one of the best things we can do is get to get in the minds of our teacher via personal dialogue.
So one of the practices that I developed from that teacher that I never forgot was once a week with every single teacher, I would go in and speak to them personally about how my grade was going, how the class was going, what am I missing, et cetera. And it turns out that if you get to know the teachers really, really well in classes, you can get good grades easily. The, which is a game I’m not justifying.
The other thing that teacher taught me was the interconnection between racism and grading. So that teacher actually got fired that year because she took a group of black and brown students and put them in a portable classroom. And then to punish them, turn the heater up to over 100 degrees. Yeah, crazy, crazy story. But I remember in sixth grade, I learned what racism meant in our education system live in my classes. I knew before then, actually, but many of those students were my best friends. I didn’t know that I was white and they were brown. I just knew they were friends of mine. And I remember being very disappointed from that teacher.
And so that’s the reason that that’s interesting is that from that moment, from the really my first introduction to grading to the end of the my college degree, I played the game of grades really, really well. And I used to think of it as a game because I recognized that every teacher of mine was manipulating my behavior and asking me to do things, some of which I agreed with some of which I didn’t. But if I was serious about getting the grade, I knew very well that this wasn’t my place to push back. Some teachers would allow me to give a little bit of pushback, but many didn’t want to hear it.
And so the reason this is interesting that this gets into the a little bit of this, that was the one section. Section two in my college degree, having played this game all the way through sixth, seventh, eighth grade, all the way through high school, graduated with a bunch of AP classes, go to college. By the end of college, I think I had 14, A pluses, 28 A’s and three A minuses. Summa cum laude with honors in my major. I’m not, my students hear me tell that story and I tell it because I want to talk about grades as a game. I actually tell them like, they’re like, Oh, you must be proud. I’m like, actually, I think I was a really good dog. I did what I was told to do and I didn’t ask many questions.
I’m actually ashamed in many ways because when I went through the grading system, I trusted that the university system that I was engaged with was doing what it said it was going to do. So when I got all the good grades and I did all the assignments, I was promised that if I did that thing, my degree would lead to employment. And in my undergraduate degree what I learned was that that was not true.
I have a beautiful story about an amazing math professor at UC Santa Barbara, where I did my undergraduate, I went, I had six classes with him, 111A, 111B, 111C – that’s abstract algebra. And then real analysis, 118A, 118B, 118C. I went to office hours at least once a week. And at one point in office hours, we’re working on a problem and he stops. It’s probably three quarters in and he catches my eye. And, and I look up from the paper and we catch eyes and he goes, you should get a PhD. And then I said, What’s that? I had never heard those words before.
And so he kind of mentored me through that process. And my senior year, I applied to two programs. I applied to the Japanese English teaching program. It was a program for the jet J E T. Since I was a young man, I wanted to speak seven languages. I still do. And I knew that I would never get a chance to be able to travel internationally for free once I had kids. So I applied to that program as part of a lifelong dream. And then I also applied to the PhD program because honestly, I didn’t really have any other choice. I hadn’t prepared my resume and I hadn’t done these things. So I got into both. Luckily, I deferred the PhD program for a year, went to Japan, taught myself Japanese in four months. That was a really, really fun thing. Like literally I bought two textbooks with no guidance from any teachers, no grades. I taught myself the entire, you know, I was reading about a third grade level conversationally fluent , I went there in August by January I was dating a woman who was Chinese.
I, you know, that was August:So $24, 000 a year times two is $48, 000 a year times four. Well, that’s $192, 000. So on our family, college was very expensive. My brother and I found ways to subsidize it. And the reason this is interesting between scholarships and our family, we were able to afford college. And these two boxes represented the entirety of my college education. So the interesting thing is I’m in graduate school, solving problems that I knew I’d solved in undergraduate. So I go back to my college one and college two box and two things happen. Number one, I couldn’t find my work. Like it took me like, like 15 minutes to find the assignment, right? Okay. So then I would find the assignment and I’d go to read my own words. I couldn’t even understand my own solutions because I had written the solutions for my teachers. And after a few months of this, I took that $100,000 and I put a light to it. I literally lit it on fire.
Another way to say this is I threw it in the recycling because it was easier for me to restructure, to recreate my solutions than it was to read my old work. And at first I was really upset with myself. And I thought to myself like, this is ridiculous. How come I did that? But the older I got, the more I remembered very few teachers asked any questions about me. Even though I was a fantastic student, I was in office hours, et cetera. I don’t remember a single teacher ever asking me, what do you want to do with the rest of your life?
I do remember a teacher saying you should get a PhD. I remember that process, but I don’t remember a deep conversation about my dreams and hopes. And then the second thing is I don’t remember a single teacher that said, Hey, by the way, instead of getting A’s where you do assignments for me, make sure your assignments are useful for your future. Right? Make sure that when you do this work, if you plan to use it, you have the option to look back on it.
And so that’s the very personal story that within my context, I felt that the UC system collected massive amounts of tuition dollars from my family. And in return, they did not deliver the promises that they made. The promise of education that I was told as a student was, when you graduate you will be employable, which was blatantly false from the standpoint of my math degree. There is a funny story, you know this joke? Out of the four things, which three are alike? A degree in engineering, a degree in chemistry, a degree in pure math, or a pepperoni pizza?
Another way to say this is which one is different?
Boz: The pepperoni pizza. It’s the useful one.
Dr. Anderson: Yeah No, the answer is a degree in pure math is different because the other three feed a family of four. So the the point of that matter though is that for me, the very personal work of rethinking grading had to do with something I learned in sixth grade all the way through the end of college, which was that grades do not do what we promised them to do, and no matter how hard we work, here’s somebody that worked very, very hard, spent a lot of time, and yet, as the quote unquote winner of that system, I still suffered greatly.
So that gets into the reason that this is advanced is because that personal grounding. The grounding of and then the other thing I guess that I will say is when I was a very young man, many of my friends were black and brown. I didn’t know that at the time. I went to a school with a high number of Latino students, a few black students in my class, which I was really lucky about, and those were the 10 kids that I tended to hang out with, not on purpose. It just I felt comfortable in that group. And when I was at school, I tended to be in that space. And the older I got, the less black and brown kids I found in my classes. So this was a consciousness that I raised in math, the higher levels of math that I achieved, the less black and brown faces that I saw. And so this, this kind of tells the story about why I came to racial consciousness as part of the process of coming to consciousness as an assessment theorist. So that’s about half the story. The second half of the story is the professional side of it. I wonder if I should pause for a minute and just say, how am I doing so far?
classroom that wasn’t in the:was starting a PhD program in:Boz: Yeah.
Dr. Anderson: I’m 39. I’m about to be 40.
Sharona: Like I said, 15 years younger than me.
Boz: I’ve got ten on you.
Dr. Anderson: I salute you both. Got a lot of love from you.
Boz: I mean that would be shocking where I’m from and I’m from, you know, the Midwest and the South and, oh my God, I really do. I hope that teacher was arrested that.
But you were talking about the fact that, You know, you started teaching without any kind of educational pedagogy classes, any kind of assessment theory, any kind of, even though I do, I am an adjunct at Cal State LA, my background is K 12. So my two degrees are in math education for the K 12 world. So I do have a lot of pedagogy background. I still never took a grading 101. In fact, Sharona and I have been doing these kind of trainings and stuff and asking people. I bet we’ve asked thousands of teachers at this point, both in the k 12 and in the higher ed, I’ve had like three that said they ever had any kind of grading course at all and usually most of those three are, it was a unit within a class.
Sharona: Well, and then for me, the very first words you said, the words sixth grade, because as I’ve been doing this work more and more and thinking back over my own story, I have two critical grade related stories and they’re sixth grade. So there’s something going on, at least with our generation of, our Gen X, maybe early millennials, where that sixth grade mark seems to be distinct in our personal stories. So I appreciate that. But I am excited. Go ahead.
Dr. Anderson: Oh, I just I want to, I’ve thought a lot about this and I think it has to do with one of the reasons that I’m so interested in and excited about working with college instructors to get the, I mean, I just love your work. I said this earlier, I’ve listened to 12 episodes so far. I plan to continue to listen. I appreciate the effort that you all are putting into making community around this and to get folks thinking differently about grading and, and Sharona, I loved one of your comments in one of your episodes, you talk about the importance of the literature review and that like spoke to my heart. I thought that was really powerful. Bosley, I love how critical you are of the system. I mean, this work is so important and I feel blessed to be in dialogue with you and I really appreciate that effort.
College instructors really, I have this statement that I make, if every college instructor in the nation decided today, suppose you had like a magic Voldemort wand and you said like, we just, everyone decides at once to get rid of grading, the entire system would crumble in five years. The entire reason that high schools use grades is because they’re trying to train people for college. The entire reason that junior high schools use grades is because they’re trying to train them for high schools. And so there’s so much power there. And I thought a lot about that particular idea, Sharona. I think the reason that that sixth grade turnover is because they’re all In the minds of a lot of educators, they’re old enough now to start doing big boy work, big girl work, big person work, and we’re going to get them ready for the grind of six through 12 so that we can get them quote unquote college ready, right?
And so I think the reason I bring that up is that in in this world that we live in of college education that I live in, at least, college instructors who are willing to do hard work, we can actually collectively have a huge impact with how grades are managed across the entire system. And so, you know, maybe that gets into the next one, but I just so appreciate that comment, Sharona. Sixth grade is really special.
Sharona: It is. So I do want to invite you to go ahead and continue with the professional side of your advanced story so that we can see where we decide to go from there.
Dr. Anderson: So the point was when I got back from Japan I recognized that year was really fun for me. I got to learn an entire language. With no guidance, it was, and moreover my last day at Santa Barbara, I go down to the bookstore and I buy the two language Japanese books, a whole year of introductory. And then the whole year of intermediate. And I worked through those two books in like three months. And it was so amazing because I would like read the book and then I would close the book and turn to my right to the 55 year old Japanese teacher. And then I would practice. So the time frame between learning the theory and putting it into practice, what Scott Young calls transfer, was seconds in many days of my life. And so this, that got me thinking about how important it was to create structures where students can practice stuff, which we’ll talk about later.
But when I got back, I made a decision that I didn’t even care if I graduated, in my mind. Literally, I said to myself, I got the degree last time and it didn’t work out so well. So if you put a slingshot to my head and you say, you have to choose, get the degree or build a career and a resume? I would choose building a career and a resume. I would do it without question. Now the good news is I didn’t think I had to choose, but the point was that from the moment I got back to the moment I finished my degree, I spent at least once every three weeks, I used to do three week cycles. So one week prep, one week execution, one week reflection doing career prep.
So I would go to the internship and career center at UC Davis. I did a bunch of Myers Briggs inventory tests. I forget all the career tests just to get a sense of what was out there. And I developed what I call now the three resume trick. And the three resume trick was, I talk to my students a lot about this. Imagine, you know, you’re on Netflix. Have you ever had this experience on Netflix where you go to watch a movie and you spend 20 minutes and then you shut Netflix cause you can’t decide which one? Well, it turns out that there are more options for careers than there are movies on Netflix. So, I realized that “you can be anything in the world” is really bad career advice. And I did that in undergraduate. I, you know, once you get your math degree, you can do anything.
And I realized that was horrible advice. And it’s related to the grading system, because what the grading system does is it allows professor not to address students career needs. It outsources the career problem to students, right? The professor says, I only need to worry about the assignments. The student says, I’ll do your assignments. And nowhere in that relationship, is there a discussion about how those assignments relate to students futures. So in my graduate degree, I developed three resumes. I said, no, I’m not allowed to do anything, I can do three things. So I wanted to get the name of a company, the job title at that company, the location and an accurate salary range. So mine were investment banking at Goldman Sachs. Industrial mathematical research at an industrial research firm. And I gave myself two, either a place like UC Berkeley or a place like Google and I wanted the Bay area version because my family’s from the Bay area. And then the third option was education. And you could probably guess which one I eventually settled down on.
Sharona: The one that doesn’t make any money?
Dr. Anderson: Which is so tough. Like thank you for saying that. I’m not allowed to drink in public. Right.
Sharona: This isn’t public. This is, this is behind the scenes.
those three. By September of:round, I don’t know September:It’s actually a valid problem that great some great mathematicians cannot teach at all and great teachers don’t necessarily produce mathematical research. And I realized at that moment that if I wanted to become a mathematical educator, which I was still figuring out that I wanted to determine my own research problem very similar to the Hilbert’s 23 famous problems in mathematics. Except that I wanted to do it for education because it turns out that the impact factor on many math papers is quite low. But imagine for a moment that we cracked the nut of great education, right? Imagine how many lives we could change?
And so I made a distinction right then. This was the professional distinction that I would treat education as seriously as I treat mathematics. So as a research, I was being trained as a research scholar from some of the, from some world famous mathematicians. And I was really honing that skill set. And I decided right then and there that even if I was not to become a math educator, even if I decided the math industry, every class that I was in, I would treat mathematics education as seriously as I treated the math that I was doing in my day job.
And so from that point forward, I determined to basically get a PhD in math education. Like I, you know, I have this joke I show this in some of my interviews. Right behind me I have three bookshelves, actually I have four, these two bookshelves, probably like 450 books. That’s my PhD in math. There’s my PhD in math education. Right? Because what is a PhD other than reading a bunch of books and doing a bunch of writing and creating new thoughts?
Sharona, I’ve heard you speak in one of your podcasts about the fact that you should have a PhD. And I wish Foothill college was a granting institution. Cause I would like just sign the honorary degree. You should have that with a paycheck, like, because you’re already generating the knowledge. And one of the ways it’s like a little club, right? We use these degrees as a mechanism to like figure out who’s in the club and who’s not. It’s an exclusive thing.
And I realized that if I was really, really serious about this, I could generate all the knowledge for myself using the guidance of those who came before me by just reading a lot. And so that’s the second part of my origin stories that I decided that I would treat education as seriously as I treated math. And at that moment, grading came second actually, we’ll talk about this in a bit. The first thing that I did was try to map every single decision that I made in the classroom back to research based, empirically validated research studies in the science of learning, the psychology of motivation, the science of expertise, the science of talent acquisition and then anti racism, which is a really interesting thing to be able to distribute that equitably.
And so from that point to this point, I’ve spent tens of thousands of hours thinking very deeply. And, and at this point, I still do research. I still produce peer review journal articles. I write textbooks. I, I write a lot of stuff on my blogs, most of which I give away for free. But my main output, my main intellectual output is teaching policies for democratic spaces. And this gets in, you know, eventually when I decided to become a teacher, I wanted to be in an open admissions educational experience so that anyone with a pulse could get into my classes.
I feel very strongly if you ask me to, to summarize my entire teaching philosophy in one word, that word would be democracy. And so. You know from the moment that I made that decision to treat math education as seriously as I treated math research till today I have dedicated a massive amount of intellectual energy and when I thought about who I wanted to benefit I wanted to be anyone who had the interest. So zero filtering mechanism. I want fantastic educations with an open door policy that is open to the public, publicly funded and open to the entire public. So those are kind of the two phases of my story. I hope I didn’t put you to sleep. But.
Sharona: No, this is absolutely fascinating. And I, Boz, I want to get your reactions to the second part of that story.
Boz: Well, and I mean, I want to thank you first for this idea of wanting to put as much emphasis on one part of it as you do the other, that I know so many people that, you know, will put a lot of energy in the math education part. Not, you know, the actual mathematics or the math research or vice versa. So to, to hear that you’ve made this real conscious effort to say, no, I’m going to take both of these things as seriously because they do go hand in hand. I mean, to really be good at one, you need to be good at the other. And you know, we can have great one sided things, but. I don’t, I don’t think I’ve ever talked to anyone that was as serious. I think Dr. Eden Turner might be the closest within science.
Sharona: Eden Tanner.
Boz: Tanner, sorry. If you’re listening, Dr. Tanner, sorry. But yeah, I don’t think I’ve ever heard a mathematician or a math educator, a math researcher say that I want to be as focused on one as I am the other. So that is very cool. And thank you for that.
Sharona: I would agree with everything Bosley said, but there’s something that was literally practically the first word out of your mouth when you started your, your thing that is, resonating as we speak with me because it’s bringing together so many strands of my life. And that was the word of healing, right? One of the things that I am learning and I’m learning it simultaneously, as many people who listen to the pod know, I have multiple jobs and I have two what I would call my primary jobs. One of them is I’m an adjunct faculty member in the math department of Cal State L. A. And the other is I’m the executive producer of a theater company.
And it has been brought to my attention the last two weeks that our theater company that we’ve created, which is for both kids and adults, we have these true professionals who have found their way to our theater. We consider ourselves educational. We are mostly a tuition based program it’s a service that you purchase. We are a nonprofit, but you pay the fee to be in the program. You’re in the program. And we have someone who has performed on the West End. We have someone who has an opera degree from a New York school. We have just these incredible people. We have someone in a cast right now who spent four years on General Hospital. Okay? And, oh, and we have someone who Bosley and I have been fans of who is, I’m not going to mention their name, but if I did, you would probably know who they are. And spent years on a famous TV series.
And these are people in our program, and I’ve asked them recently, why? You know, you’ve reached these very high level professional careers. Why are you with us? And they said, because their environments are toxic and we are healing them. And so when you said that, what you said, I was thinking back to my sixth grade experiences, which were extremely painful. I was also thinking back to the fact that I did not finish my PhD because at the time, again, being 15 years older than you, there, although to be fair, my mom already had a PhD in math education, it was not something you got if you wanted to change education at the university level.
My mom was a full faculty member, tenured full professor at a California state university with a focus on the K 12 system. And I did not want to work in the K 12 system. So I thought I needed a pure math research degree. I was not successful. I got all the way through my exams. I was working on my dissertation and I just ran into a wall and I stopped. So I never completed my degree.
And as much as I appreciate that today I’m getting to do what I set out to do, I still don’t have that degree. So this idea that the work that we’re doing is healing all of that, and to see it come together between my theater world and my professional world, my mathematics world. And my academic world is just truly a remarkable thing to be thinking about. So again, yeah, I also thank you.
Dr. Anderson: Thank you. Thank you.
Sharona: And I want to use that to move on past the origin story because I’m confident you now have however many decades in the classroom. But I want to jump all the way to a healing that I know that we need in the world right now. We have talked a lot out in the news and political space about the breakdown of our American society, and you have a blog post that you recently wrote called the harmful worldviews that undergird the letter grading system, and I was hoping you could share some of these thoughts that, that went into writing this.
Dr. Anderson: Sure. I want to thank you. So first of all, Sharona, I’m right with you later as we get into this I love the idea of healing and how important that is. And I think for any instructor who’s curious, being open to the idea of healing of going into our pain points is such an important piece of this puzzle because it turns out that if we’re not able to recognize the harms that we have internalized surviving the grading system, that it’s very, very hard to freedom dream about a different world for our students. And I find that the instructors who are most able to make changes are those that are willing to sit in the discomfort of recognizing that even though we are the winners of this system, we have come out with massive scars, and I so appreciate your courage in just saying that, Sharona and, I love that wisdom, and I, I have more to say about the PhD process, but when you ask about the three circles.
So I, I think two things are really important for me. One of them is when you look at, so let’s pretend I, I always like to think about grading like smoking. What would we say? If we go into the doctor’s office and we’re like, doctor, I’m stressed. And then the doctor says, ah, stress. I know how to deal with this. I’m going to write you a prescription for some Marlboros, and I want you to just light up and smoke that pack. And it takes the stress away every day. What would we say about that? What would we say about that, that particular doctor?
Sharona: I’m gonna let Bosley answer that question.
Dr. Anderson: They got you. So, let’s recognize there’s a billion dollar industry on the other side of that, of people who have biochemistry degrees and understand the psychology of addiction and have programmed that. So, Bosley, I love you with all of my heart. They got you, but that’s not your fault. That means they should be paying you money for the rest of your life, right? But the point is, like, what would we say about a doctor that’s, that prescribed cigarettes to deal with physical health? What would we call that doctor?
Sharona: A criminal.
Boz: We would call that a doctor that is about to get sued for malpractice and probably no longer has a license to practice medicine.
ell, it turns out since about:So that’s what I call the tear down mechanism, and I think it’s really important. Because it’s not until we take the needle out of our arm, I always called grades like an addictive drug because they gave me a lot of power, and I’m addicted to that substance, and it’s not until I as a faculty member can start imagining taking the needle out of my arm, imagining breaking that addiction, or at least thinking about why I might break it, that I’m willing to do the other part of this puzzle. That’s not the one that we’ll talk about when we’re talking about that blog post. Thanks. If not grades, then what? And I do have a good answer to that. But so let’s talk about the needle in the arm problem. What are the harmful models that undergird? And I do want to say, I published that with you all in mind. It had been in the docket for about a year, and then you all reached out to me and I was like, you know what? I’m doing it. So thank you that you’ve been dedicated to this conversation.
So. This gets into an Alfie Kohn quote that’s one of my favorite, and the quote goes something like this, that something like 90 percent of teachers cannot articulate a cogent theory of learning that undergirds their practice. But what they do, what any of us done is no less informed by theoretical assumptions, just because we can’t say it out loud. In other words, so much of what we do encapsulate theories of learning, even if we don’t know what those theories are. So, a very good question that I think is worth asking is what are the theories of learning that undergird the lady grading system? And in this case, I created a diagram with three circles. A Venn diagram, really, that intersect in the center. So you can imagine three circles that have, I guess, one, two, three, four intersections. The center intersection is the center of all circles. One of the circles is called eugenics. A second circle is called behaviorism. And the third circle is called anti democracy. And right in the center of those circles is the letter grading system.
And what I’m saying with that is that letter grades were born out of three worldviews. Those world views are eugenics, behaviorism, and anti democracy. And I don’t know if you I suppose I should give, like, a little introduction to each of those? Like, how I’m thinking about those? Okay, so the first, there’s a great podcast the Happiness Podcast, I forget her name, one of my students sent it to me, that talks about Ezra what’s his name, Ezra Stiles, one of the presidents of Yale. Who was the first person to use the grading system. And he used a four, I forget what the superior, inferior, it’s a, the the podcast title is making the grade, the happiness podcast. And in that she talks about going to the Princeton library and finding Ezra Stiles I think it was Princeton. His notebook where the grading, the four point scale, huh? Does four point sound familiar? Like 1. 0, 2. 0, 3. 0, 4. 0. Okay.
Ezra Siles was a slave owner. He owned slaves and much of his wealth was dedicated to slavery. And it turns out that in order to subjugate slaves and take over their their labor through the use of violence, many of the practitioners of that violence had to dehumanize slaves. So they had to convince themselves that it wasn’t the slave owner who was cracking the whip that was evil, it was the slave that was not human. So it’s much easier to dehumanize an oppressed group, and then take advantage of them, if I can convince myself that indeed they’re not human.
So one of the ways that this worked was if we have limited social, what I, what I can convince myself is we should be giving the resources to those who are most what do you call it? Deserving. Okay. So then the goal of power is to figure out who’s deserving and who’s not deserving. That’s the idea of eugenics. Why does the white man get to hold the whip and the black man or the black woman have to be the receiver of it? Well, God has governed that white people are superior in eugenics and Black people are non superior.
Well, it turns out that those ideas were integrated into this idea that a teacher, what the job of a teacher is, is to rank their students. So in other words, integrated into the DNA of the grading system has a long history of scholars at places like Princeton, Harvard, stanford, some of the most famous places in the world, whose leading scholars were active in the eugenics movement. These are the same people, this is, yeah, so that’s really important to say that out loud because when I uphold that system, I have to recognize that I am making a proactive choice to align with eugenicists.
And if I don’t identify that I’m on that drug and it causes harm, then it’s really hard for me to recognize why lighting up might be harmful for my health. But if I can recognize that, wait a second, deep down in the DNA of the system, in the history of the system, are racist ideas that were used to rank and sort people for the benefit of one class on the backs of another. That is in the DNA of that system. There’s no way around it. So if I choose as a faculty member to uphold that system, do you know what I’m choosing? I’m told that choosing to keep that system alive and that’s okay. I mean, I don’t think it’s okay, but if a faculty member really wants to put their flag down and say, I really want eugenics to be part of my life, like just own it.
Own the fact that you are making that statement, but let’s not avoid the reality that part of the history of grading is intimately connected with the history of eugenics. And I think this would be an offer for some historian that has more time than I have. I would love to see a book like Stamped from the B_eginning_ and Alfie Cohen’s _Punished by Rewards_ by a really, really good historian who maps the relationship, historical relationship, telling the entire story of how eugenics was integrated into the grading system. I have some some pretty good resources to document how I generated this belief and resources that allow me to know that this belief is true, but I think it would be really, really good.
There’s another book recently called the big myth by Naomi. I forget her last name. And it’s all about the assault on government from very, very wealthy people. And it tells the story how very wealthy people in our nation have made a concerted effort to undermine government in the minds of the American people through propaganda. And so that’s kind of the first pillar. I have two more, but I want to pause for a minute and kind of get reactions.
Boz: We talk a lot of our trainings when we usually start with this part that is what’s wrong with traditional grading, you know, trying to set up all the issues with it. And that’s one of the things that we lead off with is just talking about some of the history and the racist and eugenic background of not just grades, but also the bell curve. And so, yeah, that is something I, and I know Sharona, you’ve done more of that part of the research. So you’re more familiar with it than even I am, but I don’t think most people actually, I, I know most people don’t understand and don’t know that history of grades and where a lot of this came from. In fact, correct me if I’m wrong, Sharona, did you not do this in some of your research where like grades initially weren’t even done for ranking learning. It was ranking.
Sharona: It was, it was ranking the social connections of students is where it started. Yeah, this is, I’m sitting here feeling very, very uncomfortable and I know Boz knows why. Because one of the things you said about acknowledging if you’re going to be participating in a system that, that has these eugenics origins. And as I’ve become more and more familiar with it, it is becoming harder and harder. And yet, and yet I’ve always been the person that wants to do the biggest impact, the broadest impact I should say. So, so I respect and. love people who are out there on the cutting edge who want to burn it all down. The Alfie Kohns of the world. And, and the, but I want to get the 80 percent in the middle, right? I want to get the 80 percent in the middle to move.
And so it’s becoming harder for me to continue to engage in a letter grade system, while trying to move the needle. And yet I find myself in a awkward position right now where I am being given a choice that I have to make to either swallow the bile and try to mitigate the damage that someone is trying to do to the students that I’m responsible for or walk away because I can’t stomach it. And it’s very, it’s a very hard choice that I’m going to be faced with this summer.
As I try to get through to some administrators who are not currently willing to listen and it’s just a really, it’s just a difficult place to live because I feel very strongly that your thoughts are correct, although we also know that because there is some sense of limited resources in certain places in our educational system, tossing them out without replacing, like something is going to grow up to replace it, that’s going to be just as bad because we don’t have unlimited resources today, so it’s a very uncomfortable place to sit.
I cherish the discomfort, but it’s, it’s hard. And I want to acknowledge that to people who are listening, that just because we’re on this journey, and we have not yet thrown the letter grades out, and I doubt that you’ve thrown your letter grades out completely, at least the end of term grade. I’m assuming you’re still living in an end of term letter grade world.
Dr. Anderson: It is a California state law that I am, if I want to keep my job, I have to stick cigarettes in my student’s mouth at one point in the quarter. So in, I am in an ungraded classroom. I’m minimized. I literally do not talk about grades or grading points until the last day of the quarter. And at that point I ask, what grade would you like? And assuming that students have finished the work that they said they’re going to finish, I say, you should give yourself an A. I’m not going to require that, but you should do that. And so at the end of the quarter, they actually do assign themselves a grade. Many of my students give themselves A’s, which is really exciting. And I can talk all about that in fact, I don’t know that we’re going to do that today, but I’ll send you a link that you can post in the show notes. Right now we’re talking about the Identifying the theories behind the harmful models. But there’s a alternative question, which is the one that you’re asking about. If not grades, then what?
Boz: What?
Dr. Anderson: And my one word answer to that would be learning. If not grades, then what? Learning. Like we should focus on learning. And I have a really, really fun, very labor intensive, but also fun system to talk about the learning part. But I do want to highlight Sharona that you are surfacing right now something that I think is really important, which is called power dynamics. Entrenched power. In your work as an adjunct, I am 100 percent certain that you are not paid the way you should be or respect or given the respect that you deserve. So if we did not, if we did not have adjuncts, the entire systems would fail. And yet if you look at the pay rate for an adjunct versus a full time, it is a fraction that is usually less than 70%.
onger we have gotten from the:Sharona: Well, and that’s the thing. So I do want to make sure we make time for the other two circles. This episode’s just going to probably go a little long, Boz. We’re just going to live with that. We’re going to warn everybody because I’m watching the time. But I do want to get particularly to the behaviorism circle, because that’s the other one that resonates so much with me. Unless Boz, do you have anything else you want to do before we go there?
Boz: No, no, no. Yeah. Let’s talk about behaviorism.
Dr. Anderson: Yeah. The fast way that I talk about it is behaviorism, BF Skinner, Punished by Rewards by Alfie Cohen. If you haven’t read that, I would, I read that book three times. I’ve, I don’t have tattoos, but I feel like passages should be tattooed on my body somewhere. I, when I was a kid, I decided I would never get a tattoo unless someone died an untimely death, because the first time I get one, my whole body’s going to be cutted up unless I have restrictions.
Behaviorism is, is the idea. I tell this to my students. If you starve a rat to 50 percent of its life force, so it’s really, really hungry and malnourished, and then you put a rat in a cage where there’s a red button. And every time the rat hits the red button, you give it some sugar water. And every time it goes away from the red button, you give it an electric shock, not enough to kill it, but enough to really hurt it. So it feels it. You know what that rat’s going to do within a few minutes of being in that cage? Yeah.
Anybody see a connection between that and grading? The sugar water? Oh, you do what I want. Oh, here’s that little, A, you’re a good dog. Oh. And then when you don’t do what I want, bad boy, I’m going to give you an F if you really engage with that research, I think the only thing that a responsible scholar can think is, wow, this system does a lot of harm. And so one of the things that is baked into how we deal with grades is the use of punishment and rewards to manipulate student behavior. What Kohn talks a lot is that at its heart, that’s about the person who gets to determine the punishment and rewards. That’s not about the learner sitting through that mechanism.
And so the really interesting thing about that is that that be that fundamental underpinning of the grading system takes agency away from students and puts power into the professor’s hands. And so the reason that identifying that is really important is if not that then what well it turns out drive by daniel pink gives the constructive version of that. So identifying the harmful nature of that particular that circle in the venn diagram, behaviorism Well, once we identify that we could say well What does science have to say about better ways to motivate people and that’s where the book Drive by Daniel Pink comes in because in that book he shows probably like a 30 to 50 year scientific study from psychology of motivation, and he gives an answer to behaviorism. So, I mean, that’s something that comes up. What, what, what do you think, Sharona? What comes up as you hear that?
Boz: Join us next week to hear Sharona’s answers to this question and the rest of Dr. Jeff Anderson’s interview. Thank you so much for joining us and we’ll see you next week.
Sharona: Please share your thoughts and comments about this episode by commenting on this episode’s page on our website. www. thegradingpod. com, or you can share with us publicly on Twitter, Facebook, or Instagram. If you would like to suggest a future topic for the show, or would like to be considered as a potential guest for the show, please use the contact us form on our website. The Grading Podcast is created and produced by Robert Bosley and Sharona Krinsky. The full transcript of this episode is available on our website.
Boz: The views expressed here are those of the host and our guest. These views are not necessarily endorsed by the Cal State System or by the Los Angeles Unified School District.

Leave a Reply