59 – Leaning Into ROI and Communication in Leading Grading Reform: An Interview with Dr. Chad Lang

In this episode, Sharona and Bosley interview Dr. Chad Lang, the Assistant Superintendent of School Improvement at Glenwood Community School District in Iowa. Through our conversation we explore the various ways in which communication plays an important role in the impact grading reform can have on a community, a school, and a student population as well as how intentionally aligning hiring practices to your institutional values can support these efforts. We then explore the ROI of

Links

Please note – any books linked here are likely Amazon Associates links. Clicking on them and purchasing through them helps support the show. Thanks for your support!

Resources

The Grading Conference – an annual, online conference exploring Alternative Grading in Higher Education & K-12.

Some great resources to educate yourself about Alternative Grading:

Recommended Books on Alternative Grading (Please note – any books linked here are likely Amazon Associates links. Purchasing through them helps support the show. Thanks for your support!):

The Grading Podcast publishes every week on Tuesday at 4 AM Pacific time, so be sure to subscribe and get notified of each new episode. You can follow us on Twitter, Facebook and Instagram – @thegradingpod. To leave us a comment, please go to our website: http://www.thegradingpod.com and leave a comment on this episode’s page.

If you would like to be considered to be a guest on this show, please reach out using the Contact Us form on our website, www.thegradingpod.com.

All content of this podcast and website are solely the opinions of the hosts and guests and do not necessarily represent the views of California State University Los Angeles or the Los Angeles Unified School District.

Music

Country Rock performed by Lite Saturation

Country Rock by Lite Saturation is licensed under a Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.

Transcript

Dr. Lang: When you, in this idea of change, it’s, it’s, there’s no start or stop point. We have to look at all parts of the evolution and come at it from a lot of different directions. And I, and I was thinking about a post it note I found in my office yesterday from, I had Chip Heath written on it. And it says, you know, you can’t help a thousand people until you help one. You’re not really helping them when it comes to grading reform. You’re thinking about how can we, how can we communicate better so that we can actually ultimately better communication leads to a better relationship. And I think the better relationship we have as teacher, learner, facilitator, I think the more that gets accomplished and it’s, it’s better in the long run. So

Boz: welcome to the grading podcast. But we’ll take a critical lens to the methods of assessing students learning, from traditional grading to alternative methods of grading. We’ll look at how grades impact our classrooms and our students success. I’m Robert Bosley, a high school math teacher, instructional coach, intervention specialist, and instructional designer in the Los Angeles Unified School District and with Cal State LA.

Sharona: And I’m Sharona Krinsky, a math instructor at Cal State Los Angeles, faculty coach and instructional designer, whether you work in higher ed or K 12, whatever your discipline is, whether you are a teacher, a coach, or an administrator, this podcast is for you. Each week, you will get the practical, detailed information you need to be able to actually implement effective grading practices in your class and at your institution.

Boz: Hello and welcome back to the podcast. I’m Robert Bosley, one of two hosts, and with me as always, Sharona Krinsky. How are you doing today Sharona?

Sharona: I’m doing well, I guess? If I sound a little confused. It’s been a wild start to the semester. I have taken on a larger role with coordination, but I found out about the role very, very late in the summer. And on top of that, we have staff buildings that are not ready for the semester to start, which starts tomorrow. We have classroom buildings that are not ready to start. We have instructors that are flying back from overseas and their flights have been canceled, so they’re not going to make it on time. We have instructors who don’t have their staff email accounts set up yet. So we’re doing some very creative and imaginative co teaching for the next several days to kick off our freshman courses. So I’m doing fabulously.

Boz: Yeah, I just had to send out messages to all of my two classes because they’re not in the building that’s affected. Just to remind them saying, Hey, if you’ve seen all these announcements, this doesn’t affect us. Our classes do start Wednesday. Please be there.

Sharona: I’m really excited to introduce the guest that we have in the studio today. With us today is Dr. Chad Lang. He is the Assistant Superintendent of School Improvement at Glenwood Community School District in Iowa. He has over two decades of experience as a teacher, administrator, and district leader, and particularly extensive expertise in curriculum development, grading reform, and professional learning communities at work. So Bosley, he is you if you had gone admin, which Bosley is trying very hard not to. Under his leadership Dr. Lang managed to guide his school district to achieving a national model PLC at work district status and a National Blue Ribbon Award for West Elementary from the U. S. Department of Education. You have a bunch of awards, but one of the big reasons that we wanted to talk to you today is your work specifically in grading reform because you co authored the book, A Parent’s Guide to Grading and Reporting: Being Clear About What Matters with Matt Townsley, a repeated guest on the pod. So, welcome, Chad and anything to add to that bio there?

Dr. Lang: No, and in fact, thank you so much for the great introduction. It’s always awkward to hear that all come together. And I’ve been fortunate enough to work at schools that have won some of those awards and get to just be a part of it. But yes, I’m a big fan of the pod. Super excited to be able to join you, Boz, Sharona. It’s been a blast. I do follow as a regular listener, so I’m excited to be able to join as a guest.

Boz: Well, thank you for listening. And I just want to thank you again for that book that you coauthored with Matt Townsley. That is a great book. Anyone that has not read it yet. We’ve talked about it on one of our episodes with Matt Townsley, the sportscaster of alternative grading as we like to call him. But yeah, that, that’s a unique book because it is really focused on the parent side of it and the parent communication, which from someone who’s been doing this for a few years now, I can absolutely testified that the parent part of this, and communicating can be very tricky. So that is a great resource for anyone, if you haven’t already checked it out, please do so. And thank you for joining and welcome to the podcast.

Dr. Lang: Thanks again.

Boz: So one of the things that we always like to ask on the podcast here when we have a new guest is just your origin story. How did you get involved with this crazy world of alternative grading?

Dr. Lang: Yeah, you know, I was very blessed. It was by accident, really, I was went through a college preparatory program that was that I would call fantastic, but traditional. And so I’m sure there were some elements of high quality, assessment and maybe even a little grading in that undergraduate many years ago. But, you know, none of it really stuck, unfortunately, because I went right into continuing to develop and deploy, I was a high school social studies teacher, the same grading and assessment methodology that was done to me. And there’s always a great paradox about that, right? We often lament, like, I hated when this happened, I thought it was so unfair when so and so lectured about this and the assessment was about that. And what’s the first thing we do when we get in the classroom, we turn around and replicate so many of those same practices.

But I was just lucky in, I think year five of teaching, I happened to land at a school district that asked for a volunteer from each department, high school to study grading practices and to be on a one year pilot really just researching our grading practices and kind of going down the journey of what I call the Rick Wormeli video series. But much more thorough than that and just taking time with someone from every department in every school building in a K 12 district to really examine grading practices and our school improvement kind of plan at the district I was at right outside of Kansas City, Missouri at the time. And just spend time to understand, you know, what standards based grading actually is, and is that something that we should be moving towards to be better communicators of student learning.

s a game changer. That was in:

Boz: I love to hear from people that have been involved in this for so long. I mean, I, with most of the circles that I’m in, I’m, you know, one of the more experienced people and you’ve got a decade on me. So I love hearing the experience from someone that’s been in this world and in this environment for so much longer. That is. phenomenal that you’ve been at this for, like you said, almost 16 years now.

z is that those challenges in:

And I think that’s where I’ve tried to capture some of that school improvement effort when I’m helping schools or helping our own folks in our schools. And the neat thing about our organization, you know, even if we have a low turnover in staff, there’s onboarding that needs to take place about basic simplistic organizational things. How to make a copy. Who’s my mentor? Where do I go to get my paycheck? You know explain to me much less grading reform. So, you know, I get to every year think mentally how I’m going to onboard someone that’s coming in at say zero out of 10 with, our current staff, that’s anywhere between three to 10. Right. So it’s always new and the same at the same time.

know, in your early years of:

Dr. Lang: Yeah. Two different ways, actually, by being an adjunct professor at two different universities. One at the University of Nebraska Omaha. I’m in my third year, third fall semester of teaching. Teaching, grading and assessment in a graduate education program, a master’s degree program, and it’s about 30 typically first or second year teachers who are in a cohort together moving through like an 18 month program. It’s phenomenal. And kudos to the University of Nebraska Omaha for really embedding that class. And then on top of that, hiring a practitioner in a school district to be able to teach the course. And I’ve really enjoyed it. I think I’m going into my third class. Third time doing that. And then I’m teaching a two credit asynchronous grading and measurement course in the university of Northern Iowa was undergraduate program for mostly like sophomores, juniors.

And that has a totally different challenge because the graduate course is every other time in person for like two and a half hours. So we can really get in and actually do a lot of the workshop type based things I do with practitioners in the school, whereas in the asynchronous courses has its challenges. There’s different, there’s going to be a different deployment of the learning. And of course, on the one hand, I’m working with teachers who are truly living the teaching, assessing, grading world, like truly in their first semester. In fact, they’re just starting with their students, first sets of students right now. And I’m right along with them in that first semester versus the undergraduate course where they’re in their first course or two into the college of Ed as an undergrad. So two different ends of the spectrum for future or current educators, but great to see them embedded in the programs.

Boz: Yeah. And big kudos to those colleges for, like you said, actually starting to have these courses and have it part of, you know, the pre-service teachers education and part of their programs. Is that something that you’re starting to see more colleges and universities starting to do? Because I, again, I think I know of one school out here in the California area that does have a grading theories class as part of their program now, but That’s the only one I’ve heard of.

Dr. Lang: I think I’m seeing more assessment specific embedded into more undergraduate programs. And because I’m the person that’s the recruiter for our school district. And so I’m out recruiting oftentimes college graduates are soon to be college graduates. I’m sort of using some inquiry along the way to ask some questions to actually start to screen for a predisposition towards having a standards based mindset, right? And so it’s interesting. I have these conversations with candidates and I am finding that holistically, as a generalization, candidates have more of a broad sense of a varied assessment. And then that sort of sparked this thought about, well, how, what impact would that have? I mean, the, the better, you know, about formative assessment, the more it challenges that everything’s summative in terms of its communication or it’s calculative. It’s just natural for you to start asking some of those questions because the assessment being formative is about what you’re doing with the information, not how you’re calculating it.

As you guys know, and you start asking yourself, well, it doesn’t really make sense that I’m calculating this then. And you start asking more questions. And I think you start to see more change earlier in your career. So I think being more educated in truly types of assessment, the purpose of assessment, criterion versus norm, all those things, having a basis of conversation gets you thinking earlier, which definitely starts that question about grading. So I am seeing it in candidates as I recruit. Definitely there’s times where I said it’s okay just asking. I’m just curious if you have any background with standards based standards, reference grading, or sometimes folks call it lots of different things. As you guys know, competency based grading, evidence based grading, the list goes on.

And I said, nothing against you. I’m just curious. And so then I’ll do a little bit of an interview and say, well, what do you know? And, and and try to see if there’s some common ground. And it’s not a prerequisite to work for us, but certainly it’s good information for us to know. And our candidates are learning that information somewhere. So I’m excited to see that.

Sharona: Well, and it’s interesting to me to hear you say that we’re starting to see progress. One, area where I have some perspective is I have been in and around mathematics classrooms personally for 35 years, but I’m a second generation math educator. So my mom has been around math classrooms as an instructor since before I was bored. And she was heavily involved with trying to change how we teach math in the K through 8. To bring in what at the time was called cooperative learning and is now part of the the active learning umbrella. And I remember towards the end of her active career that she was feeling a little discouraged. She had gotten 25 million dollars in grants. She had worked in all of these amazing things and she felt like there was essentially no progress. And I would say maybe about seven years after she finally retired, I saw some of the people that she hired for their first tenure line positions. really come into their own, and they’re now leading these big inquiry learning projects and, they’re making real traction at the higher ed level.

And we’re seeing the research come out on active learning, the, the big famous study where they are saying if this were a medical trial, we would have stopped the placebo, right? Which is, which is traditional lecture because we’re doing damage. So I feel like even though she didn’t see it, during her career time, I saw it just after she retired. So I have some hope because active learning is now everywhere. Doesn’t mean everyone’s doing it, but everybody knows about it. So I feel like that could be where we are at with grading reform because even my mom didn’t know about it, not really. Or if she did, she never talked about it to me and I am where I am because of her.

So I really hope and feel that If we break the cycle in so many different places and you yourself, you know, you’re breaking it, you’re giving it to undergrads, you’re giving it to grad students, you’re giving it to new teachers, you’re giving it to experienced teachers, you’re working with schools, you’re working with districts, you’re working with parents, like if we can just break it everywhere, that’s going to be, that’s going to be totally amazing. That’s one of your jobs is being this adjunct. You’ve mentioned hiring. What do you do right now? And what does that look like in your day to day?

Dr. Lang: Yeah, I have a great hybrid position at our school district. And for Iowa’s size, we’re actually fairly large as school districts go. And so we’re really blessed to have my position. And it’s, it’s called Assistant Superintendent of School Improvement and HR. And that and HR sort of was added on about, oh, three or four years ago. When we really realized that, you know, to be able to do the things that we want to do with curriculum, instruction, assessment and culture and well being of our students, we got to make sure that we have a coordinated effort towards recruiting and hiring and that not everybody fits and our principals were doing a lot of it on their own, doing the very best they can, but they’re sort of, you know, really focused about fit, which of course is important. But what about philosophy? What about predisposition? What about if they get transferred from one elementary to another in our organization?

And, you know, a big piece of that has allowed us to develop sort of a screening to focus on those values around curriculum, instruction, assessment and then grading. Like, do you have a disposition? To believe that we should be communicating what a student can know or do up against a set of learning criteria versus all the other alternative methods that might be out there that could dilute or report inaccurately.

And by allowing me to sort of help coordinate that for a district, I by no means hire every teacher independently on my own. But it’s allowed us to work together as a collaborative team of school leaders to make sure that we have a trust with one another, because as you well know, I’m sure we have to have agility in our H. R. Department. I have to be able to be in Iowa City on a Tuesday morning at a college fair and be able to call our principal that afternoon and say, Can you set up a zoom interview? We’re not. We’re not in the position, at least where we’re at, to be able to queue up a folder of 10 math applicants. three weeks from now, interview them, there wouldn’t be any left. So having that agility, having that trust means we have to be able to coordinate and identify the values that we’re looking for in our educators around our curriculum instruction, assessment and grading strategies.

And so that level of trust and collectiveness around our team is something that I oversee and help develop and goes hand in hand. Like I’m the one that helps to recruit you, brings you to the table. If you end up interviewing and coming on for us as a teacher, I’m going to be your first person to provide summer onboarding to curriculum instruction, assessment, grading at something we call the summer Institute. And then I’m going to be right there along the way with our instructional coaches actually supporting you in the grassroots efforts towards assessment and grading specifically in ongoing fashion. So as a level of support. So it’s, it’s a great position that I’m so fortunate to be able to do. So once the HR functioning stops that for that person, the school improvement function kicks in.

Boz: So, I don’t know if you have anything like officially written down, but if you do, and you’re willing to share, I would love to see that interviewing protocol or that kind of script that you were talking about cause my school, we do a lot of hiring by committee and I would absolutely love to see that, that kind of protocol, that kind of whatever you want to call it.

Dr. Lang: But yeah, no, I’m, I’m happy to share it. Like I can literally just share it right now. It’s just four C’s and we just value four C’s. So are you coachable? and questions that get at that, right? Are you coachable? Can we come along? This is a learning process. We’re never done. And just when we think we have a good sense of how we’re gonna do a reassessment strategy or procedure, we have to evolve and pivot. And so we’re never really done. We have that coachability in mind that seniority is valuable and important, but it doesn’t exit you out of growth mindset and being coachable.

Being able to be a collaborator is a second C. Like, are you willing to work together to grow one another? Putting the professional in the learning community is super important for us. Third, having high character. We can’t supervise your way into a great school. You have to be great for kids. Parents are entrusting us with their kids every single day to do what’s best for them. And then lastly, is competency. And actually, that is last. And when I say competency is content has been commoditized and you know that our students can get access to information they want to learn well before we’re able to present it and facilitate it to them. And so while that’s important, it is last. And then it kind of phases us, and that’s really the screening of what we do.

What’s been amazing, and I’m sure you guys have thought about how I can help you with that. So take your school improvement mission and vision use AI around your pillars like those four pillars for us. Suggest questions for a high school math candidate around those four pillars. It’s and then we work and develop and evolve to use this. Obviously, it’s the same types of questions to get at those values. And particularly, obviously, grading assessment comes up maybe through for example, collaboration. I might ask a question around grading and assessment that focuses on would your first go to, if there was a discrepancy, if we both taught integrated math one and you had a completely discrepant score from one another on a common assessment, what would be your first thing to do as a really hypothetical? And if their first thing was, well, I’d ask the principal to just tell me what the grade is. That’s not very collaborative. And, not that that’s a deal breaker, but it would be awesome that if we had a candidate said, well, it seems to make sense that we would have already established proficiency ahead of time since we do appeal. We’re a PLC at work district and I could just work with my common collaborative partner and we would have had that figured out and I’ll just run across the hall and see what they think. And I’ll cover up the name. That’d be an awesome answer. And so, but you can get answers all in between and it gets at both collaborator and a little bit of grading and assessment knowledge. So. Yeah. I, we sort of do that process and procedure and, and frankly, AI has helped with that.

Sharona: You know we were just saying that we were doing some, some PD earlier today on authentic assessment in the age of AI. And I’ve been very struck recently about the places that I use AI in my work because I’m a math educator. I also run a theater company, so I’m constantly writing and I had to write some class descriptions for my theater company that I was like, you know, I didn’t have a personal stake in these, they were marketing fluff pieces. So I just dumped it into AI and said, hey, write a class description for this title, pulled up what it gave me, looked at it, said, yeah, this is good enough, pretty good. I would not do that in writing an assessment question, at least as the whole process. But I do like it as what you’re saying of using it to create these questions that can get at what we’re trying to get at. So that, I think, is fascinating.

Dr. Lang: It’s a thought partner, and it really helps you, because like, if we were to work with a traditional consulting company, pick a name, to say, Hey, help us really redesign our HR process to identify teachers in a shortage market who have a predisposition to be a good match for us on grading, assessment, curriculum, instruction. They’d be like, we don’t have such a product. A, we can’t customize it all the way down to your level and your context, and B, we’re not experts in those areas. So we just don’t ask questions about it. And then what you often get is, and there’s some great stuff out there, is just fit, culture, fit, fit, fit. And fit is an important element, but we have an ultimate responsibility for the students to make sure learning’s happening. And so sometimes it’s just. Not a good match philosophically, not necessarily culturally.

And and I think while it’s an easy trap to fall into is to, yeah, but you know, they’re a veteran teacher. I know their former superintendent. I know their principal. I’m just going to hire them. You want that full roster as soon as you can for next year. It just doesn’t work long term or either that worse yet, you start to sacrifice what you believe in because of the staff that you bring on. And that’s not good for, that’s not good for students overall.

Sharona: I have a question. How the heck did you convince somebody to let you be in this position with that mentality? Bosley would love to like hire you and put you in charge of all his stuff. What led your district to be willing to go down this route?

dards reference grading since:

We actually have three and maybe more if you think about some culture, climate, and some social, emotional learnings, things we have going on as well, and you have no one interfacing these that Tom Guskey wasn’t with Rick Wormeli with Tom Schimmer and you know Phil Warwick and Tammy Heffelbauer at the same time in our school saying, here’s how we’re going to make all this work together so that everyone’s on the same page. It’s like, I always say, it’s like taking the back or the front off of a grandfather clock and seeing all these inner working pieces. Schools just don’t show up that way. They actually have remnants of past mechanics, past leaders, and they’re not made to fit together. And so you take that and then you see this hiring shortage where people come on and they burn in flames because they’re like, I just want to teach and shut my door. I was really good at that in my last job and they have no initial competency because of our systems. They don’t seem to be linked in place. And they’d flame out and they have competency. They just don’t feel competent. And when people aren’t competent or they don’t feel competent, they have no confidence. And when they don’t have any confidence, they can’t grow. And so it was just really a good, it wasn’t overnight. It was just a conversation with our school board and our superintendents to just say, Hey, this seems like a natural link. And we didn’t have an HR director. So it was pretty easy to say, well, you should pick up maybe some of those from a strategic sense and so develop some of these things, obviously over four or five years, just to bring that coordination together.

Sharona: You know, what’s striking me about this Bosley is. That’s how we tend to say that grading reform is the linchpin of all of these other things we’ve been trying to do in math education. We’ve been trying to do active learning. We’ve been trying to do inquiry. We’ve been trying to get growth, you know, growth mindset in. We’ve been trying to do group work. And one of the reasons I came to grading reform is I had tried and I’d heard again from my mom for so many years, this is the way to go. And I’m not having those hit it out of the park experiences in my classrooms. They’re fine. They’re better than a lot of traditional lecture, but I didn’t have the students coming to me and saying, Professor, you changed my life.

And I was taking that very personally. Like somehow I can’t make this work the way all these other people have made it work. And for me, the big epiphany was my grading was way too much in the way. And so making that jump, that leap to the grading, it integrated all the other stuff. I do have. A PLC, which by the way, is almost unheard of at the university level, and I’ve really got one that’s been smacking me in the face this week that how great my current team is. So shout out to my team. It’s allowing the active learning to be a piece of the puzzle. It’s not the whole puzzle. It doesn’t solve things by itself, but it’s providing that value in the classroom. So I don’t know. Thoughts on that, Boz, how these seem to mirror.

Boz: Yeah, you’ve said it before how, you know, this was the linchpin for you. You know, I actually started , my reform journey, not with grading, but with PLC work with going back to the Dufours. And those, I think you mentioned the PLC at work at learning by doing, but how all of these, these things can really be at ends with traditional grading and how that traditional grading can be in the way, but it’s interesting that, you know, that was kind of what brought it all together for us. But now you’re almost in a role where you’re doing that at a human level, where you’re bringing, you know, helping bring all these other ideas together and making it into a system that is really effective and highly awarded and highly recognized. And yeah, I. It’s, it’s amazing. It sounds like a position every district needs to have tomorrow, but.

Dr. Lang: Yeah. And so you feel for you feel for districts that maybe have too many of me. And they, and what, what I feel like is they end up just doing it for everyone else, whatever it is, is like, let me deliver you this hand delivered packet of procedures. And then on the flip side, what I see a lot more often is, you know, We’re a smaller district of three principals of three different buildings. And we put our shoulders together and we just make sure the wheels don’t come off the bus. And we’ve got some great people who do about 24 different things here. And we’re just trying the best we can.

And so the question is, and they’re all doing things that they think are the best for kids and learning. I hope what we have to figure out a way to support one another, whether you have my position or not, is. Whatever you’re invested in, does it mesh, does it match with your goals for grading and assessment? I think if you don’t think about that, you’re going a little bit against yourself. You’re going against the grain. For example, I work with school districts that are like, we really want to have better grading practices, whatever they want to call it. And then probably usually the very next thing I ask them is, what’s your curriculum process like? How is it organized? And if it, if they have no semblance of identifying learning targets, if they have no process for that, if it’s foreign, it doesn’t, it’s just given to them or it’s worse yet. It’s like a textbook. Then it’s going to be really hard to actually make a communication grades in aligned to that. There’s nothing to align it to. You say we’re standards based grading to the unit to test the chapter two presentation. It’s like, you’re only going to go so far.

And you know, I’m an old basketball coach. I’m not old, but I did that many years ago. And an early flaw and early air in my head coaching experience was I wasn’t very good, but I was a major learner. And so I went to as many coaching clinics as I possibly could. I watched Jimmy Bayheim out at Syracuse and John Calipari at Kentucky and all these people. And philosophically, they’re all different and they’re all really good. And I would try to do like everything they do. But the problem is having a really good half court zone defense doesn’t go well with a full court man to man press defense. They’re both good in their own right. But if I would have brought, and I did do stuff like this we’re going to do both of these team and I tried to put those in play, there was only a marginal how good I was going to be at either one of them because they actually didn’t help one another. They were actually a little bit juxtaposed philosophical. There’s a lot of good things to do that schools can do to improve learning, culture, climate, well being but you have to ask yourself, do you have someone on staff or as a team? Do you have a way to facilitate? How do things work together or even opposed to one another? And one of the things I’m passionate about in my doctoral research is like extracurricular participation. How does that go with grading?

You know, we know of, you know, no pass, no play rules and things. I mean, there’s a whole lot of ramifications that if you’re going to be very zero tolerance about things in your grading philosophy, then you’re also going to have to be great communicators that you’re going to have less participants in your extracurricular part program, which could have ramifications for attendance and truancy and funding and community action and all kinds of things. So I really just, I’m very passionate about, you know, figuring out a way in which grading assessment is essential and as it relates to your other school improvement levers.

Sharona: Yeah, that definitely, so much of what you said hits home. One of the things that we have at the university that I don’t think you directly have with K 12 is if we fail students, there’s a risk that they’re going to drop below satisfactory academic progress, and if they drop that below that, they may lose their access to school housing and dormitory meal plans. And for many of my students, that is the only housing and the only food that they have access to. So now I’m talking about, oh, hey, you got a D in precalculus. So we’re not gonna let you eat or have a roof over your head. That’s gonna be great. Not. And then the other thing is you’re reading my mail about textbooks and curriculum. I’ve had a recent conversation with someone who is. I was very proud of having done a course redesign, and I asked them why they did it. They couldn’t really answer me other than to say because we wanted students to learn better. And then I asked them what they did, and they were very proud about the new textbook and the newest homeworks aligned to the textbook, so, yeah.

Dr. Lang: Well, you’re certainly not going to be surprised that my grad students who are first year teachers on a stipend, not even a first year teacher salary they’re Shout hooray when I don’t assign a textbook for the course and but rather, you know, a hodgepodge of lots of different great resources that I’ve used over the years with practicing educators and it’s an evolution. It changes and they of course enjoy that, but it gives it gives a greater focus to this is what you’ll have to do to collaborate with your team to make a best decision around assessment, for example, and consequently, maybe grading. And so we provide some evidence, we provide some literature, we hash it out together, because there is no one right way. You know, that’s the other thing is being, feeling like you’re indicted, that you’re doing something wrong. You know, the only thing wrong is being unethical and inaccurate about what a child can know or do. you know, you’re doing the best to be a great communicator to parents in the district. And so it’s been, it’s been fun. They don’t like it if , if they were super organized and they want to just be able to knock out content, it’s not a good feeling for them, but if they seeing the aha moments and the stars align from reading practitioner based articles and research, maybe a video series compiled with a scholarly article on maybe motivation, then it comes into play. And I teach that course in a standards based way. So Cool. It’s all about developing proficiency, which directly translates to their classroom. So that’s been a lot of fun. But it, it’s a mindset.

Boz: So we’ve been talking about the class that you teach and some of the other changes, but Sharona at the last grading conference over on this last summer, you led a panel on what was called change in leadership. And I kind of want to talk some about that with you, Dr. Lang about you know, what, what’s next? Like what needs to be done next to really enact you know, true change and what is change in leadership? So Sharona, do you want to kind of give a little bit of feedback on was there?

Sharona: So what we were really looking at there is this was a mathematics conference. It was higher Ed education and mathematics. And the question we’re asking is a little bit sort of the biggest scale of change leadership, which is how do we get to a to and over a tipping point? What do we have to do to keep the progress going? The reason that we have, as a community, adopted the words alternative grading, is because ultimately the goal is that this becomes grading. This, like, I want that word alternative to be a placeholder for when in the future you say grading, you mean all of these different ways that measure student learning, that measure and report student learning to whatever degree it can. So when we say change leadership, we’re really talking about how do we get further along the scale to this tipping point.

Dr. Lang: Well my thought is first let’s lean into ROI (return on investment). What does the data tell us when done well and staying committed? And we can and we can communicate proficiency of student learning more accurately, more consistently. What’s the R. O. I.? How does it feel to go to school there? What is the students feedback? What are the parents feedback? Do they have a better or worse understanding of what their child can know or do? And what are the ramifications when students don’t know things? What are the actual ramifications as it relates to career in college or what does it look like? And we talk about, you know, you’ll hear folks who you think that this is another sort of one off reform or something in that.

Well, there’s, there’s a lot of things that get baked into, you know, some of the concerns about not grading behavior and compliance and turning things in and all of that. Well, those are all still important to all of us, of course, but I think you lose track of the entire sense of grading, which is communication at a K 12 setting where we need to think of grading as communication and we need to lean into where people feel greatly communicated with. And that’s a big part of our book. Grades as a form of, Currency and transaction. A grade at grading someone, you know, in our part of the country, stakes are graded, meat is graded. That process is degrading. Right. Because it has a finality to it. Yes. The, the cow’s been slaughtered, the stakes in the store. It has a grade USHD, A grade to it. Is that our intent when we’re talking about learning about polynomials? Is that the end goal? And so I’m not talking about banishing grades, but I’m talking about replacing it with competency and communication. And what do you stand to gain? What do you stand to lose if we don’t accurately communicate what students can know or do? And it’s both the systems, but more importantly, the students and their parents, you know, who can argue against that? And that that’s been a that’s been a great success for us. When working with parents.

Sharona: I would say, I know some people who can argue against it, and this is something that I like for us to acknowledge so we can think about how to deal with it, which is, there are people in our field who do believe that we should be ranking and sorting students against each other whether it’s for elitism or promotion supremacy of some sort, or because they just think it’s the right thing to do, or they think that their own identity is. Tied up with I made it through and I’m at the top, but right now grades absolutely are used for ranking and sorting in part because we have resource scarcity at different levels such as that the graduate and professional levels and things like that So I don’t want to just ignore the fact that many people there are people who will say what we lose if Everybody can succeed. It’s sort of like if everybody’s excellent and nobody’s excellent is the argument.

Dr. Lang: Mm hmm

Sharona: I clearly don’t believe that. It’s not that if everybody’s excellent, nobody’s excellent. It’s like, can we grow everybody to be excellent? Don’t we want everybody to be excellent? But what do you say to those who say, but we need to rank and sort students fpr xyz reason.

Dr. Lang: Well, the first thing I would, first thing I would say is, are we talking about a first grader and making vowel sounds? Are we talking about preparing candidates to get into Harvard Law School? I think there’s a big difference in terms of why we would want to rank and sort of first grader, why we want to rank and sort an eighth grader. By and large, K 12 education is criterion based. And there’s a basic set of expectations that a person’s going to need to be basically successful. And there are degrees of proficiency of learning anything. We’re all cognizant of that.

And so if we are going to be relegated to ranking and sorting people for any of the reasons that you provided, then it surely should be on agreed upon criteria ahead of time. Rather than a hodgepodge or kitchen sink of compliance related activities and wonder why we see the amount of remediation we see at the college level when high school graduation rates seem to be record high in many states, as well as just the average GPA of high schoolers. And so it seems like you guys have a better connection with higher ed than I do, but it seems like a connection might be that candidates or college candidates are consistently underperforming in their readiness to be successful while at the same time having high school GPAs or purport just the opposite. So I think that’s tough to wrestle with. I’m not saying there’s not a place to rank and sort someone when you’re trying to make a decision for a position or a scholarship, but let’s agree upon what those competencies are and is it, and is it a level playing field to start with? And then by and large, you know, then there may be a time in place for that.

But if we’re talking about a K 12 set of competencies it’s not really relevant. And so I appreciate you bringing up that point because I think people take the opposite argument and say, well, you just want everyone to pass. Well, of course I want everyone to do well., I don’t want, if passing means they have the basic competencies. To be a contributing citizen to the U. S. Yes, I definitely want them to do that. But let’s not make that synonymous with our degrees of mastery or proficiency. I think that’s a big lead.

Sharona: Well, and that’s what Dr. Benjamin Bloom in his famous article Learning for Mastery says that there’s 5 percent of the population that is extremely good in some specific area, you know, the savants or whatever. And there’s maybe 5 percent of the population that has some significant challenges that will mean that they will struggle to learn basic competency. But then he said in a industrials or a post industrialized society, you need the 5 percent at the top plus the 90 percent at the middle to all be competent in order to maintain an industrialized society.

So that’s his argument, is you need to set that bar for what basic human competence looks like. So, you know, a literate citizenry, one that can argue, one that can reason, one that can use quantitative and qualitative arguments. He’s like, we should be striving to get all 95 percent there. The challenge with that is if you have 95 percent there, then that is an electorate and a citizenship that is much harder to fool. And it’s much harder to control if you have bad intentions. So just, I never thought that my work would lead me into the philosophies of human existence, but here we are.

Dr. Lang: And we’re deep into it today.

Sharona: Always when it comes to grading.

Boz: So, I mentioned earlier a little bit about the book that you co wrote with Matt Townsley. What is coming up next for you? Because we talked a little bit earlier and it sounds like you’ve got a whole bunch of, of things coming up real soon.

Dr. Lang: Yeah, there’s some some really great opportunities to present nationally National Council for school leaders of mathematics have an annual conference in Chicago. Matt Townsley and I actually will be doing a workshop for school leaders of mathematics, their one hour workshop, which we’re excited about and supporting, you know, thinking about grading, really grading reform in the mathematics classroom and sort of the ironies of some of the poor mathematical strategies that could be used in computing a grade and sort of the irony in that. So getting school leaders with some ideas about starting their journey or helping them along in their journey in their schools. Later in.

Sharona: There you go. We have a whole presentation on the misuse of mathematics in the measurement of student learning.

Dr. Lang: I bet you do. There’s a great irony there for so many, but we’re looking forward to that. It’s called beyond ABCs and 83s is what our presentation’s about. So that’ll be fun. And we’ve got some good practical action steps and strategies for school leaders. And in November, a colleague of mine, Ben Haynes, who’s a instructional coach in the middle school for us here in Glenwood, we’re going to do what’s called a spark Intel at the American middle level educators conference, annual conference in , Nashville for early educators.

So first year teachers or early educators on some great strategies for students to track their own learning using learning progressions and proficiency scales to sort of A, help students have a better sense of keeping track of their learning or proficiency and B, lighten the workload a little bit for early career educators who might think they have to grade everything and turn it back in the next day to their students.

Boz: So I’m curious about that first conference and workshop are talking, talking about because that is something that’s come up. And a few of our recent episodes and that is, and also just with working in my district you know, LAUSD came out with a new grading policy back in February of this year, working with some of my colleagues. And we’re, we’re finding a, a real need and a real deficit in the knowledge and the training that our admins have on a lot of this. Whether it’s, you know, understanding alternative grading and traditional grading at a base level to, you know, really understanding what work needs to be done to help support and train teachers on this. So I, I’m curious, you know I don’t want you to give away your presentation, but what, what do you see is there? Like, what do districts and, and, and education programs need to be doing with the admins to start like bringing them along to a point where they can really support the teachers in the classroom and the movements that are happening in different pockets to really take hold.

Dr. Lang: Great. That’s an awesome question. Well, there’s three pillars to that kind of workshop or that presentation for school leaders to better support grading reform. And the first one is just having a better and deeper understanding of the curriculum instruction assessment process and the alignment piece I talked about earlier. You know, you might’ve came on new to the community or the district or the school one or two years, and people have been involved with the curriculum process for 10 years in that school. And so you’re new. And so you got to get up to speed with that. Does our grading reform match and what can I do if it doesn’t? And in talk about and have a better and deeper understanding of our curriculum design and deployment.

The second thing is a little bit more towards kind of changing language and maybe even thinking about your SIS or your grading actual electronic gradebook if you have that and thinking about shifting away from anything that’s gonna encourage you to quantify learning towards qualifying learning and talking about quality of learning in depth. So helping administrators really think about, you know, what’s our language of our school. You know, things like you need to have so many things in the grade book in each week, you know, having sort of these procedures that feel like their support supporting and consistent, but actually prioritize quantity versus quality.

Sharona: We call that hacking, hacking the grade book.

Dr. Lang: There you go. And lastly, just looking at your procedures to enhance communication and transparency, not just relying upon the grade card. In our book, we call it the triadic communication. In chapter five, it’s the parent triad, where the student is at an equal footing in the communication triad with both the school the educator and the parents or the guardian. So we’re talking the same language. We happen to think that it’s great to use some sort of proficiency scale or learning progression. So that you have a common template that we’re all sitting at the same, you know, communication piece on the table, focus on learning and not just completion. And so there’s, that’s an hour. That’ll be quick, but that’s really our focus.

And I think, you know, more broadly looking in the future, Boz, I happen to have a hankering to be learning and studying a little bit about generational differences. And I’ve been focusing on that in my work in HR because schools often have four to five generations of employees and that generational difference, as Tim Elmore’s work would show, it can be some of the most friction. And so I think about your question about school leadership is what generation? are most of your school leaders from. And so how are they trained? Did they ever get exposed to reform grading practices as an educator? Most school leaders were teachers first. And so how can I lead something I haven’t done that sort of knowing doing gap challenge? And we’ve done that work in our school district, focusing really on leading Generation Z teachers and what kind of leadership moves we can make to better match the needs of Gen Z, both in recruiting and maintaining and recruiting employees we have.

So it looks different. And I think, you know, if you are trying to validate communication from two generations prior, and I’m just being generalizing, And you’re missing the boat and you’re saying, grades are communication, grades are communication. Then I have a whole set of teachers emailing parents, and I have a whole set of teachers calling parents, and I have a whole set of teachers trying to run them down at ballgames. Let’s talk about your son. So that’s three completely different ways, and they all said, we are communicating with parents. And so maybe they’re led by one leader that says, that’s the right way. And so just being cognizant of that.

Boz: You know, that’s, that’s really interesting. I, I never really thought about that especially since I am, you know, not just 20 years in, but I was a little bit older for normal starting time. So I am one of the older generations of my school, but yeah, that generational difference and how we approach things, I, I would love to have you back in the future when, you know, when you’ve gotten some, some research in this done and found, and, you know, come to some findings, I would be fascinated with, with hearing, you know, just, What that looks like and what that ends up you know, what path that leads you down.

Dr. Lang: Well, here’s one thing I would share with you to marinate on and your listeners. And I got this from Tim Elmore this summer in Omaha, Nebraska. I had an opportunity to see him speak and then talk to him. And he said, think about this. The age of authority is going down generally in our country. So for us, that means younger deans, younger provost, younger, literally their age. younger principals, younger vice principals, associate principals, school leaders of different capacities, but the age of maturity is going up. So what ramifications could that have on grading as it relates to our conversation around communication?

So I have the authority to say, I want all of these parents to be in the loop. We want to improve our communication. We want to make sure they know what grades mean. And then on the flip side, How well can the folks, the staff that we have delivered that? And what does it look like to them? Have we had a collective conversation about what that looks like? Because sometimes the best intentions can actually lead to more confusion. And one of the things that Matt and I are very passionate about is let’s make sure our students know what we’re talking about. When we’re in the middle, late elementary, middle and high school, our students should be able to explain to our parents how how things work. And that goes back to that parent triad I was talking about.

Boz: Absolutely. And that’s, that’s a beautiful point. You know, we, one of the things that Sharona and I have both come across is, you know, whether or not our students are able to, you know, either by age or by maturity handle this. And we’re like, yeah, they’re there. You’re talking about freshmen in college. What like, here’s examples of people doing this in fifth grade. I’ll be like, but yeah, bringing the students in and, having them be able to verbalize and explain. And I know you guys talked about that in that book and that triad and absolutely love that. But we are kind of coming up on time. So Sharona.

Sharona: I had one last thought I wanted to share on that. Because a lot of the time we bridge between K 12 and college. We have an even bigger challenge in some ways at the university level, because we’re not trying to communicate to parents, but we are trying to communicate to our students. And so on the one hand, we’re telling multi generations of professors, you need to communicate with our students. But our students methods of communications are changing so rapidly that we are struggling to even reach them at all. Let alone, because they’re not always in our courses. They’re not always in our classrooms. We want them to communicate certain ways. They want to communicate different ways. And it’s not necessarily reasonable to ask every generation of professor to have every method of communication available to them, so.

Dr. Lang: Right. I totally agree. That’s, that’s attention. That’s attention between between those. And I think we just have to lean into what is it, what are the core combat, the values that we, we both can agree upon and on both ends of that spectrum, right? And then also just identifying exemplars of things ahead of time, whether that’s communication, whether that’s what proficiency would look like. That’s something I’m going to really lean into this fall with my With my, my courses, because man, I’ve really struggled with. I have a vision. I can just see myself 25 years ago, sitting in that seat and how I would have taken notes or how I would have done that. And to have that rose colored glasses is a challenge. And now you think about communicating in grades. Wow. You know, that that can look different. That’s a great, great point, Sharona. I think we have to balance that tension and not go too far in either direction.

Sharona: All right. Now you can do your close out Boz.

Boz: Well, just what thank you again for coming on Dr. Lang. It was great having you. And just what, if there’s any kind of last closing statements or anything that you wanted to leave out on.

Dr. Lang: I just want to thank you guys for the invitation. I’m a big fan of the podcast. I think as Sharona pointed out earlier, When you, in this idea of change, it’s, it’s, there’s no start or stop point. We have to look at all parts of the evolution and come at it from a lot of different directions. And I, and I was thinking about a post it note I found in my office yesterday from I had Chip Heath written on it and it says, you know, you can’t help a thousand people until you help one and you’re not really helping them when it comes to grading or reform. You’re thinking about how can we, how can we communicate better so that we can actually ultimately better communication leads to a better relationship. And I think the better relationship we have as teacher, learner, facilitator, I think the more that gets accomplished and it’s, it’s better in the long run. So I appreciate that paradigm and I, and I value that you brought that, brought that to light in this episode. Thanks again for the invitation.

Boz: It was great having you. And I love that the better relationship, the better where the results are going to be. A absolutely true. We hope you guys have enjoyed this as much as we have, and like I said, love to have you back on again. Especially if you do get any kind of traction and results from that generational tension study that sounds really interesting. And then for our audience, we will see you next week.

Sharona: Please share your thoughts and comments about this episode by commenting on this episode’s page on our website. www. thegradingpod.com. com or you can share with us publicly on Twitter, Facebook, or Instagram. If you would like to suggest a future topic for the show, or would like to be considered as a potential guest for the show, please use the contact us form on our website. The Grading Podcast is created and produced by Robert Bosley and Sharona Krinsky. The full transcript of this episode is available on our website.

Boz: The views expressed here are those of the host and our guest. These views are not necessarily endorsed by the Cal State system or by the Los Angeles Unified School District.

Leave a Reply