51 – Reflecting on Standards-Based Grading with Joe Zeccola and Ashleigh Fox

In this episode, Joe Zeccola and Dr. Ashleigh Fox join Sharona and Bosley as we look at a critique of standards-based grading written from someone in the trenches, already working in alternative grading. We discuss many of the main points of the article as a way of self-reflecting on our practices as we explore this world of alternative grading.

Links

Please note – any books linked here are likely Amazon Associates links. Clicking on them and purchasing through them helps support the show. Thanks for your support!

Previous Episodes for Joe Zeccola:

Previous Episodes for Ashleigh Fox

Resources

The Grading Conference – an annual, online conference exploring Alternative Grading in Higher Education & K-12.

Some great resources to educate yourself about Alternative Grading:

Recommended Books on Alternative Grading (Please note – any books linked here are likely Amazon Associates links. Purchasing through them helps support the show. Thanks for your support!):

The Grading Podcast publishes every week on Tuesday at 4 AM Pacific time, so be sure to subscribe and get notified of each new episode. You can follow us on Twitter, Facebook and Instagram – @thegradingpod. To leave us a comment, please go to our website: http://www.thegradingpod.com and leave a comment on this episode’s page.

If you would like to be considered to be a guest on this show, please reach out using the Contact Us form on our website, www.thegradingpod.com.

All content of this podcast and website are solely the opinions of the hosts and guests and do not necessarily represent the views of California State University Los Angeles or the Los Angeles Unified School District.

Music

Country Rock performed by Lite Saturation

Country Rock by Lite Saturation is licensed under a Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.

Transcript

Joe and Ash

===

Ashleigh: But, again, folks have graded in that way because it is so overwhelming to grade all of the aspects of an essay, and so it is just easier to find the things that are black and white and can be measured by a single standard but yeah, I mean, I’m really convinced by the piece of this article that talks about the problematic nature of just that single standard.

We can hold students to super high standards and still not have that. It’s a really limited focus that eliminates the beauty and the creativity.

Joe: I would just say, just to build on what Ashleigh just said, that’s a problem for English teachers regardless of grading system.

Boz: Welcome to The Grading Podcast where we’ll take a critical lens to the methods of assessing students learning from traditional grading to alternative methods of grading. We’ll look at how grades impact our classrooms and our students success. I’m Robert Bosley, a high school math teacher, instructional coach, intervention specialist, and instructional designer in the Los Angeles Unified School District and with Cal State LA.

Sharona: And I’m Sharona Krinsky, a math instructor at Cal State Los Angeles, faculty coach, and instructional designer. Whether you work in higher ed or K 12, whatever your discipline is, whether you are a teacher, a coach, or an administrator, this podcast is for you. Each week, you will get the practical, detailed information you need to be able to actually implement effective grading practices in your class and at your institution.

Boz: Hello, and welcome back to the podcast. I’m Robert Bosley, one of your two co hosts, and with me as always, Sharona Krinsky. How are you doing today, Sharona?

Sharona: I’m doing well. It’s just a busy time in life. Lots of school stuff, lots of theater stuff, lots of family stuff. Lots of parenting stuff. So just really, really busy. How about you?

Boz: Well, at the time of this recording I haven’t yet started my cross country road trip. By the time it comes out, I will have been well into it. So that’s always fun, but also the thought of being in a vehicle for 20 plus hours, that used to be easier to do when I was in my mid thirties. Now that I’m 50 being in a car that long starts to take a toll.

Sharona: Well, I don’t know how you do it. The longest car trip I’ve ever driven was nine hours. And that’s about my limit. How you do 20 plus hours straight through. I mean, hats off. If I had a hat, otherwise I could take your hat off, but hats off to you, that’s just incredible. I want to welcome, we have two people in our virtual studio today. This is our first time having two returning guests. So I’d like to welcome back Joe Zeccola and Dr. Ashleigh Fox, ’cause we actually get to say Doctor now. So welcome back Joe and Ashleigh.

Ashleigh: Good to be here.

Sharona: And just to remind people Joe Zeccola has been a guest for us a couple of times, and in the show notes we’ll link your previous episodes, Joe, but Joe’s an English teacher at John Marshall High School in LA Unified School District.

And Ashleigh is a professor of writing and other stuff. And now the newly minted PhD at the Community College of Allegheny County . So it’s our second Pennsylvania one in, in just a couple of weeks. So welcome Joe and Ashleigh. Now we’re asking you, we asked you back both of you, and this should be interesting cause you guys have wanted to meet each other, but this is your first time actually meeting is virtually because there was an article. that came out about a year ago written by a gentleman by the name of Arthur Chiaravelli. I think that’s the closest I could get. It’s on the Grow Beyond Grades blog, and it’s called We Need to Talk About Standards Based Grading. And one of the reasons I wanted to talk with both of you about this article is the person who wrote this actually is a practitioner of standards based grading.

And I think that as we continue to move into this world and as critical as everyone outside this world is on us, it behooves us to be critical on ourselves. Boz, do you want to add a little bit about why you wanted to get them on?

Boz: Well, the person that wrote this is writing this as a practitioner of English. Like is writing this as an English educator. So there are some arguments that are made in here that I wanted to get you guys both on both because both of you’re English instructors, Joe, you’re at the K 12 world, Ashleigh, you’re in the higher ed world, and also to get a slightly different views because this is written from someone who does standards based grading.

Whereas Ashleigh, I know you do more contract or ungrading, Joe, you’re more on the what used to be called mastery grading or EGI, which is really similar to standards based, but not quite the same. So I’m curious to see his arguments through your lenses to see if those same issues are still there or are they different or are they completely negated by different alternative grading structures.

Sharona: So Joe, why don’t we go to you first? What was your first initial reaction when we sent you this article? Anything that comes top of mind?

Joe: Sure. It, and thanks for having me back. It, it was sort of funny cause I read that I read the headline and I was like, I’m not going to like this. Cause I just, I, I just there’s too much fight already at the last thing I need is someone jumping off the train before we get it really rolling.

And then I had the same reaction you had, Sharona, which is this guy, in addition to be one of my Italian brothers or cousins, as they say he’s clearly on the right track. And what really got me right away where I just started laughing is the end of the first paragraph of the article, he just says, I have no desire to return to the toxic practices of the past, late penalties, one shot assessments with no opportunities to redo or retake zeros and 100 point scale, et cetera.

Well, that’s the primary fight we get from people. They get very wedded to all these things that that Chiaravalli calls toxic. So right away, I’m like, well, I’m already good. Wherever he’s going, he agrees that that’s what sort of sent us there. So just to sort of frame my take on the whole thing, I was talking to, I work with new teachers for the district. I help train them and I do as much as I can to talk about grading because we still don’t have a formalized grading program to teach them this. And one of the things I pointed out was what we call EGI and I’m much more wedded at this point to alternative grading that you all use. Someone said, well, I can see the benefits of both.

And I go, what’s both? And they couldn’t articulate. I’m like, the benefits of punishing kids? What’s the benefits? And my point was, there’s pretty much two camps. There’s the people who want to keep doing what they’ve been doing. And the rest of us over here who are trying to figure out the best way and that’s got to be evolving.

So I feel like this is a natural healthy process in that to call into question some of the standards based grading practices that became rigid that became, again, following in the footsteps of what came before it. So to me what what he’s doing is what we should be doing constantly, because we’re clearly part of something that we don’t know what 100 percent works yet.

We just know what doesn’t work. And we’re trying to get rid of that and move towards what does. And I know listening to Ashleigh’s episode as well. It’s this constant evolving way of trying to get students into the same place we are. So we’re actually doing teaching and learning.

Sharona: How about you, Ashleigh? Initial reactions when we when we sent you this article?

Ashleigh: I was really drawn to the section that critiques standards based grading for privileging what can be measured. Because I think in Joe’s and my field, there is so much excellent progress that simply is not measurable. The problem with focusing on what is measurable, and I’ve been guilty of this, and Joe, I bet you could speak to this too, it’s tempting to just devolve into focusing only on an essay’s Grammar, syntax, MLA format.

We’re not even thinking about things like the power of ideas. I think it’s really possible to do alternative grading in a way that does focus on those things like the beauty and power of words and rhetoric and persuasion without being kind of obfuscated by all of those tiny measurable things. So as I was reading this article, I was just thinking, you’re kind of creating your own problem here by having this version of alternative grading that maybe doesn’t quite fit and it’s an easy tweak.

But I thought I would be very frustrated too if my only approach to grading in a writing class were what could be very concretely measured. That wouldn’t work for me at all.

Joe: Can I real quick jump on that real quick?

Sharona: Yes.

Joe: So it’s, it’s an area where this is one where I would love to, if we get a chance at some point, Ashleigh, just to chat with you offline about this too, because I’m still working it.

But because of my origin story started where Bosley was in South LA, this is less of an issue for my philosophy than it is, I think, for a lot of higher ed people in that I prioritize thinking in all my classes. And because of my experience learning UDL, the idea was try to find as many ways to see it as I can.

So far I’m only getting really two, which is writing and speaking and listening. But the whole point is I structure my Socratic seminars to be essay prompt based. So I’m hearing the kids engage them because I had a very significant statistically significant number of kids in South LA who could say an essay better than they could write it.

And if that’s happening, I can see it. I can measure that, right? And then also just the whole idea of you want to teach them to write formal language for an essay, but that can’t be the only way you do it. And my certainly my big bugaboo is part of my national board certification was really looking at the fact that almost everything language teachers assess is written and we have to get away from that.

So this is certainly something I’m very much on this train and constantly trying to figure out where to go with it. And when I was reading it, I had the same reaction. How can we, how can I find more ways to measure this without taking away the fun of the collaboration and things like that?

Sharona: Now, I have to admit, I love what you’re saying, and I am having a visceral reaction. And I want to see if Bazzi’s having the same one. You are giving mathematicians the hives by saying not measure stuff. And we do have a lot of STEM educators on here, so I want to make sure that we acknowledge why this is such an important conversation, especially as we try to bridge across disciplines. Because Ashleigh, before we were started recording, you were saying you’re having your mathematician friends not coming on board. Whereas I’m having the opposite, where I talk to people like, well, I can see how this works in mathematics, but it doesn’t work in English. So Bosley, what’s your reaction to what they’re saying?

I mean, cause I, even though I very much believe what you’re saying, I’m still getting an allergic reaction to the lack of measurability.

Boz: We’ll see but that’s, and that’s, I think, where our our differences in disciplines do come in because I mean, you and I, we can mathematically prove a theorem to be correct or not, you know, one plus one is two. Like, there is a.

Sharona: Only in certain number systems.

Boz: Yes, only in certain, yes. One plus one could be 10. But it’s, but it’s still, there is a correct. Can you really said like who says there’s a correct when it comes to writing and rhetoric and like it’s it’s more subjective, I think, and that’s that increase subjectivity needs to be accounted for, and it needs to be recognized.

And I think that’s why, because Sharona, you and I are not, never have been, and I know I will never be, any kind of writing instructor.

Sharona: You should not be allowed near students trying to learn to write.

Boz: Yeah. This is only done audio. I wish we had video on to see the faces of Joe and Sharona when I made that comment, cause they’ve both seen my writing, Ashleigh, you’ve not had the horrors, but.

Joe: Yeah, it’s, it’s, it’s impressively bad, but I want to say on the air so people can hold this, hold me against this as bad as your writing is, my math is worse, so.

Ashleigh: We absolutely could not do your job, Boz, so, yeah. No, I’m struck by that wording that you’re using, Boz, like this idea of correct. Because I always notice this kind of divide in how my mother, who was also an English educator, and I talk about student writing. My mother would always say, I’m going to correct papers and she was a stickler for grammar. She grew up in the 60s and went to secretarial school.

Like that is what she was taught and that’s what she brought to the classroom when she was eventually an educator. I never say that I’m correcting papers because that goes along with the idea in this article that we are really limited when we behave as though there’s like this single standard of correct writing.

earing Asao Inouye say at the:

That’s why I am here in this alt grading space. So, moving away from this idea of correctness, because, yeah, like, empirically there are some things that are good and bad, right or wrong, but for the most part, even if those things are measurable, how do you do a holistic grade? Like, if someone’s grammar is perfect, but their ideas are full of logical fallacies, is that an 85?

Is it a 92? Those numbers are, are really meaningless in a holistic assessment context. So I just think it’s much easier to say strengths are here, here are your weaknesses, work on this next time. And that has been effective, largely, with the writers I work with.

Boz: Yeah, the, the author of this brings that up as one of their issues with standards based grading. And I, I love this quote that it, It mentions from the National Council of Teachers of Education, the NCTE.

Joe: That’s English.

Boz: On the students, do what?

Joe: It’s NCTE. NCTE is English.

Boz: Yeah, that’s what I said, didn’t I?

Joe: You said education.

Sharona: You said education.

Boz: Oh.

ed it up. This was adopted in:

Joe: I think one of the interesting things about that Bosley is the hostility around adjusting off of that, I think Ashleigh would agree, is very similar to the hostility towards adopting alternative grading methods because most English teachers grade the way they were graded.

So they’re just perpetuating that tradition again. It isn’t about the why, you know, for me, I say this to, to young teachers all the time, like my national board certification and most of my success is due largely to the fact that I had an amazing English methods teacher and I’ll shout her out.

Her name is Yvonne Devons Hutchinson. She was over 40 years in the district when I met her. Her whole career in South LA, she lived in South LA, went to school there, came back, taught there. And basically, you know, I have no idea how old she was because she didn’t look old at all, but I remember looking at her going, I can be you when I grow up.

You’re pushing 70 probably and not only relevant but cool and literally pushing aside all of these models of correctness. So when I got to the point where I had to assess for national boards, I was just pushed to all the best practices without even realizing it. And that helps because again, you’ve got someone who right away, she’s thinking about how do I fight white supremacists? A woman of color who spent her entire career trying to sort of trailblaze in English.

But again, that was just someone who came into it. You know, I have, not unlike Sharona, I have a theater background. So I was not wedded to an orthodoxy when I came into to an English, an English training classroom.

But most of us are very wedded to the orthodoxy. We were we were taught with

Sharona: So I want to move on to the second heading. Because I agree with you, Joe, about what we’re wedded to and full disclosure, the second heading in this article is something that I’m really grappling with. So the heading says, standards based grading pairs comments with scores.

So I am still in the standards based grading world for my work as a math teacher because I have sort of this idea that I want you to, as a student, I have this discrete object that I want you to show me sufficient evidence of. And therefore, once you’ve shown me sufficient evidence of this thing, then I mark it off.

It’s complete, however I define complete. But what this author is saying that whatever you make those rubric marks, whether they’re levels or numbers or marks or labels or scales or progressions or colors, it doesn’t matter. The minute you give them this complete or not complete, they treat it as grades.

And yet I am struggling with, as someone who teaches quantitative reasoning, so a lot of what I do is not teaching standard mathematics. I may have the opportunity to go back into a set of mathematics that builds on itself, but right now I teach quantitative reasoning, and I’m trying to get my students to see that they need to be able to do certain types of thinking, and when I think they’ve shown me enough of that, I’m like, you’re good.

That’s a chunk. I want them to continue, but they’re good enough, and I add up these chunks of good enough, but this, Author is saying he’s still seeing the telltale complacency and discouragement. So responses to that, who wants to go first?

Joe: Well, I was trying to let Ashleigh go because this seems like the wheelhouse of what y’all were talking about in her episode.

Ashleigh: I can, I can speak to having seen a similar dynamic when I’ve used that concept of flash feedback for three for exceeds expectations, two for meets, one as an indicator to please submit, and zero for something missing.

Students just interpret it as a percentage, like a two out of three, they think, oh, that’s a 66%, like I’m failing, even though that’s meant to be pretty much like a, an A minus or something in there. So it, it is really difficult, I think, to break away from the grade like mentality even when you remove formal grades. So this part of the article I nodded along with.

Joe: Yeah I mean one of the things I say and it’s interesting one of my colleagues told me that it’s starting to bleed out of my Classroom, which is good as I’ll say because I use the four point I use the classic Marzano scale with the three being proficient and you know, especially this is something Bosley I talk about for K through 12 I need that four as a way to note that someone’s way beyond where I need them because I may need to be pushing them to a higher level class or whatever.

But the four is irrelevant to my grading scale. It’s only the one, two, and three that affects A, B, C, D. The four is just, I’m noting you’re way beyond where I need you to be. Anyway what I say is you got a three on the four, right? And I say it over and over again. I write it that way so it’s never out of four because that’s the problem.

But I would just argue that this is the challenge of being practitioners of alternative grading in a world that’s so percentage based that for me, it’s constantly constantly about rediscussing and re pushing that dialogue about what are we doing in this room and the good news is the kids that buy in, come back and go, I just had them write letters to next year’s class, and I’ve already read a bunch where they’re saying it gives them the freedom to not feel like they have to succeed right away, and they can focus on learning, but it takes a lot, and I just think until we’re the dominant orthodoxy people doing what we do, this is going to be the tension. Because every other, the water they’re swimming in, to use that metaphor, right, is percentage grades everywhere else.

That tension is naturally going to happen. They’re constantly looking for scores until we get everyone intrinsically motivated, or most people, you know, towards the idea that their job is to learn in this room. I don’t know. I don’t know how we undo that entirely.

Boz: Yeah, and seeing this is this is because this is one of the areas that I really wanted to talk quite a bit about.

And sure you and I bring this up quite a bit. You know, the research and looking at when you give students feedback, whether it’s a percentage, whether it’s feedback and a percentage, or just feedback, which one was actually the more successful one for students taking in the feedback was the one without the numbers.

So we’ve always, in our trainings encouraged this, but this is saying, or part of this argument is saying no, if you’re using a rubric, if you’re using numbers, letters, levels Jedi rankings like I’ve used before, it doesn’t matter what you’re using. It’s still a ranking and that ranking ends up dominating the attention of the student over the feedback.

And I’m grappling with that, like how, like without going to some form of ungrading or, or a contract, like, how do you get around that?

Sharona: And I’m not sure I agree with this. This is one area I’m like, I’m not sure. And part of it is, so I have definitely gone in courses where I’m not coordinated with other people, I only have three levels, complete, revise, and you didn’t turn it in. And those are not marked with numbers. There’s a, there’s a check, a pencil to revise, and an X for you didn’t turn it in.

And the X is just, it’s just for my tracking purposes. And so the students know whether or not they turned it in. And yes, they go there first, but there’s some sense of, I have to, at least, because again, I’m in the college level. So this type of student is already a sophomore or a junior. So they’re pretty far up the developmental scale.

And I am getting a lot of pushback from my administration that students don’t know how they’re doing. And for all that we want to say, we just want them to grow as learners, certainly in higher ed, those grades are becoming more and more and more important for their future. So I think that there’s an element in my mind of I am hurting the students’ stress levels and anxieties in a way that counteracts the potential growth mindset they might get when they’re looking at a final grade on a transcript and saying, Am I going to get to go to grad school?

Am I going to get to go to med school? Am I going to get to get into nursing? Am I going to become an engineer? Like, I wish the grades didn’t matter, but they really matter, still. The final grade, not the intermediates. So I’ve done everything I can to strip the meaning of the grades in the middle, except “I’m complete with this chunk.”

Because I do have these chunks. Even in my most writing related class, which was my history of math, I had chunks, like, one chunk was describe the impact of race and gender on the identity of mathematicians historically. But separate from that, I had describe the impact of numerical systems.

Well, they needed to complete a number of these things. So they needed to know am I done with race and gender or do I have to go back to it? Like so I don’t know what where do you grapple with that? Do you guys have that same kind of thing in your classes where they have things they have to complete?

Ashleigh: Yeah, I tend to do what you do in terms of just the check mark in the grade book now. I basically i’m like everybody else i’ve done every version of this and just revised it, often even in the midst of a semester but what I what I have found to be really, really good for the low stakes formative assessment is just that checkmark to say yes, you did this thing that we are scaffolding so you can do the bigger thing.

And of course, in our class, that’s going to be the signature research essay or a creative writing portfolio, something of that nature. So they’re just constantly climbing these stairs to that. So, I mean, it’s a limited story in a sense because we might have a student who puts three sentences into a journal entry that was really intended to be a more robust piece.

So, is that complete? That’s why I do like that option for please resubmit because then you can kind of catch the things that need to be redone. But when we get into the labor of all of this, and that’s also mentioned in the article, that this can be exhausting. That is sometimes problematic for instructors who are working with alt grading because they say, I’m already assessing so much.

And now I have to go back and reassess, especially when the reason is because somebody did less work to begin with. So I don’t think that check marks capture the nuance, but they can simplify things on my end and I would argue on the students’ end as well. They cannot make the case that they don’t know how they’re doing if they see a sea of green check marks.

That’s your indicator that you’ve done something. If you don’t see it, you didn’t do the thing. You’re not on track.

Joe: And you just said my favorite, my favorite phrase. What I’ve started to use is, the three is you’re doing the thing, right? The two is you’re almost doing the thing. The one is you’re not doing the thing yet.

The four is you’re doing the thing at the next level, right? And. So I guess I, I have two responses, Sharona. Well, let me get philosophical for a second. If we all believe, and I think we all do, and that sort of Guskey/Bloom idea that we want all of them at A’s. The problem then is going to be there at higher ed, they’re going to resist that because there goes the chance to who’s getting into the best grad schools if everyone’s getting A’s, right? So I don’t, I don’t even know what you do with that.

But to me, the idea that rubrics or proficiency scales are causing stress. I mean, if you’re teaching someone to shoot a basketball, there’s shooting a basketball and there’s not shooting a basketball. Are you doing the thing or not? And we have to be able to do that.

Sharona: Well, and to clarify, yeah, to clarify what was causing stress was the lack of rubrics. This, this person was saying in the article, the author basically is like, just get rid of all these rubrics. And I’m like, that’s where I’m like, I need something to tell them how they’re doing.

Joe: I’m with you a hundred percent. I think that the idea that we get rid of that, like, then what are we doing? And again, I’m all I’m down with students helping to revise rubrics using student friendly language, helping kids to be clear on what the goal is. But certainly one of my big aha moments when and it was a big deal when Bosley and I were teaching together that at least at least our administration bought into was.

You could tell a lot in a room if you walked in and asked the kids what they were working on. Did they know? And how many didn’t? And to me, there’s the key to proficiency scales. What are we doing? What does the thing look like? So yeah, I don’t, I don’t know how you do without that. Like, you’ve got to have some shared reference.

Sharona: The author is saying you do it strictly with comments. And again, all I’m saying is this is my personal resistance. And I want to be open to the idea that I’m wrong because there is a lot of research that shows that the minute you slap a label on it, it causes problems. My concern is when you don’t slap a label on it, are you creating other problems that are not being acknowledged?

Boz: And isn’t this one of the, like fundamental separators between ungrading and other forms of alternative grading, is most of the practitioners that I know that would say that they do some form of ungrading. It’s just that they give copious amounts of feedback, but they never actually put a rubric score on or something or anything like that.

Sharona: Or a mark of any kind that says complete.

Boz: Yeah. It’s just, here is, here’s the feedback. And like I said, my, my courses that I have taught and continue to teach. I don’t think the benefits of doing that would outweigh the harm of doing that, whether it’s, you know, the stress of students not knowing where they’re at, the stress and pain that the parents can cause, both me to them and them to me, because parents not having any idea, because at the high school level, I, I can’t. I just, I don’t see how I can do that. And then.

Ashleigh: There can be, there can be a lot of structure within ungrading. And in fact, I think a lot of what the research and just conversations with practitioners of it are telling us is that we need structure. Within it. So yeah, some people implement ungrading where it is just more of a, Hey, do the things you want to do in the order and the time you want to do them.

But I think at this point, most of us who fall under that ungrading umbrella still have very clear deadlines, are using rubrics. We’ve just taken the numbers off. So it’s the exact same standards, learning outcomes, all of that. But we’ve just removed maybe the mathematical piece that for writers does not serve them to give an accurate portrayal of how they are doing.

And really in a writing class, I strongly believe that if students just do all the things, back to to that phrase Joe, their writing will get better. If they implement feedback. If we engage in those feedback loops and I always have students meet with me. I have a dialogue about their writing and then I have them email me about what they understood my suggestions to be.

And also my praise, right? I want them to focus on what they’re doing well, as much as what they can improve upon. And then they make those changes, they get more feedback, but this does not have to happen without really high standards and, and very, very structured approaches.

So I think for me, the ungrading mechanism is really just saying, let’s back burner these numbers. We never need to, to make those a part of it. Even at the end, cause we just have a strict letter grade system.

So no one’s getting an 89 percent on anything. We’re just, we’re just going by comments and then final letter grades.

Boz: All right. So then I have a question for you, Ashleigh, as a practitioner in this form of alternative grading, do you agree or disagree with the argument that the author is writing here that if you’re using rubric, even if you’ve taken the points off the fact that there’s columns and there’s categories that that is still going to cause that diminish of motivation and that oh, I’m reading I know I’m in this column and therefore not actually doing the feedback. Have you seen that or have you seen that not happening?

Ashleigh: I think that because in a, in a writing class, students can be so, in so many different places on a single rubric. So, so there isn’t a cohesive, there isn’t really cohesive messaging about you are in the excellent category unless somebody is, in fact, turning in a paper in which everything falls into that category.

Honestly, that’s not usually the case. There’s something that can be improved upon in that draft and revision stage. So I think my students are not overly focusing on those categorical pieces of the rubric, but back to our earlier conversation, they do often focus on just what is going on in that gradebook and still feeling both like it mimics traditional grading. And then also saying we don’t know exactly where we stand. So, it’s far from a perfect system. But I think what we can all come back to is there is no perfect system that is going to serve every learner. I do strongly feel like alternative grading serves most of my students better. And that’s why I continue to use it.

Even though, I’ve had a number of fails and things that I really need to work on. That’s also why I love it. I’m learning alongside them. Like it’s so humbling. It’s yeah, that’s why I stay in it.

Joe: Bosley, there’s, there’s a set, there’s two, is it two sentences? You had two sentences at the end of the paragraph for this section that Sharona was bringing up. But once you pair a score with comments, fixed mindset kicks in and undermines the benefits students get from feedback. As many of us who worked in standards based grading have discovered, the conversation veers predictably towards resentment, discouragement, or complacency around the grade. I just, I flat out reject that.

That it is certainly an issue you need to work on, but the idea, like, to me, this it infantilizes our students. And it also like, I want to see the data that this is something that is not based on how we implement the practice. Because without those criteria, what are my comments aligned to? To me, I think that feels more subjective to the students because they don’t know where I’m coming from with the comments, whereas what my students will tell you is the first thing that happens to them, and I just read this in letters yesterday to next year’s students as advice is they get used to getting the scores, they didn’t expect because what they’re expecting is to get A’s on everything they turn in.

And then they realize, Oh, wait, that’s not what we do in this class. And my point to them is, if you’re getting an A on the first assignment, Are we in, are we in June? Is the year done? You know what I mean? Like we’re learning these things. And so the idea that I can’t put a score with comments and then just to add real quick caveat, unlike Bosley and his Cal State LA classes and, and Sharona and Ashleigh. I’ve got EdCode. I have to put grades in the gradebook.

So I’ve got laws I have to follow, but I’m saying, I see it with my own eyes. There are the kids who are hung up on grades, there are the kids who are not hung up on grades, and I make it a big part of my practice to sort of break that down and say, we’re trying to learn it here.

I don’t know what you do if you just surrender to that concept as opposed to pushing back against it in terms of how you practice alternative grading with students.

Boz: So if we’ve got any ed researchers that are listening, here’s the next ed research that needs to be done. Let’s redo this study. That Sharona, you and I talk a lot about, about, yeah,

Sharona: the Butler study,

Boz: the Butler study. Thank you. Redo that with this because reading this, it was one of those. I don’t know if I agree or disagree, but I think it’s a great question to bring up. And, a large reason why I wanted to have you guys on here to kind of get your opinions, but right now the four of us are talking about opinions and so is the author, I think this would be a really interesting that Butler study to revisit and redo using, whether it’s standards based grading practices or just any kind of alternative grading with rubric and seeing if there, which of us are more correct based on the data. Does it take away, does it add, does it have, you know some zero effects? So.

Sharona: The thing I like about the article is this idea that we need to keep revisiting our assumptions. What I don’t like about the article is that this author clearly made a number of practicing decisions when he was in standards based grading that I think he thinks is the definition of standards based grading, and I disagree. So one of them is this idea that, like the headline says, standards based grading pairs comments with scores.

Says who? I don’t have scores, I have emojis, or we use languages. The next header says, standards based grading is exhausting. Says who? I mean, yes, we’ve all experienced it when we’re learning how to do it, and people have heard me talk on this podcast numerous times about flooding myself with grading. But he says in this paragraph, “I’m subconsciously beginning to build a case for the grade I’m going to assign, especially if I know it’s a lower one.”

Well, I don’t assign grades at any point until the very end of the semester, but I use standards based grading. So again, I feel like there’s a little bit of a mixing between this particular author’s implementation of standards based grading and what standards based grading really is the way we’ve defined it with the four pillars.

So I’m a little bit, I started losing it a little bit in the middle. Because the very next header is standard space grading isn’t timely or accurate. So I’m like, well, wait a second. So I don’t know, did you guys see anything in these sections where you’re like, okay, maybe the header’s not a true representation of what the author was trying to say? Or, what do you think of these sections? Those three, specifically.

Ashleigh: I was really struck by the section standards based grading is exhausting because in my dissertation study, I looked at the lived experiences of Instructors using all kinds of alternative grading. I had folks doing standards based, ungrading, contract grading, labor based grading across the board, across disciplines.

And though people acknowledge the amount of work and the fact that it can be exhausting they didn’t, they really universally, and this is echoed in the research as well, they say that it is also energizing because you are getting to focus on the things that are meaningful. These are dialogues about learning, focusing on growth, celebrating student success, and removing that element of defending grades.

Really focusing on the punitive aspect, all of that, that can really just heighten the tension and do a lot of damage to the student teacher relationship and then, of course, our enjoyment of our practice. So I don’t ever want to minimize anyone’s perception of how difficult it is to do assessment in general. Because it’s hard no matter how you approach it. But I did feel like this was quite a bit out of sync with a lot of the other research and just stories out there.

Joe: Ditto. Yeah, I mean, I feel like, Sharona, to answer your question, it’s like a vent session for him. And, and again, when anything becomes too rigid, I think that’s problematic, but yeah, like for me, as an English teacher, as a teacher of writing, I mean, grading, we have the highest grading burden. That’s where, that’s where teaching ELA in some way is, that’s what makes that job hard. Everyone’s got their own thing and their job.

There’s no hardest job in teaching, except maybe, maybe I think we could all agree, teachers of kids with special needs because of all the lack of support from federal and state, whatever.

But in terms of teaching, the burden for us is grading too much. I would argue, exactly what Ashleigh said. It’s made my job easier. I’m scoring a bunch of stuff as we speak to finalize grades and I’ve been out. So I’m just reading kids responses because I was, I had hip replacement surgery.

So I’m home, but I’m scoring. And what I’m doing now is they’re doing revisions. My reads are targeted. I’m reading to see if they’re doing the thing I needed them to improve on. I’m not re holistically grading the essay. Oh, they did it. Good. They’re now using evidence to back up what they’re, what they’re writing.

So that’s making it easy for me to target. And just a quick story. I had a kid last year, whose name obviously will remain nameless, who I could not stand. One of the most frustrating kids I’ve ever taught in my career. Kid’s brain was in his own way, would fight us. Between me, my amazing, I had an amazing student teacher in the room who now teaches with Bosley and I had really high performing students. And I was trying every possible combination of resource to help grow this kid. And the kid would just fight and the kid just was convinced he was a genius no matter what he did.

But anyway, like, I don’t know that there’s ever been a kid I disliked on a personal/professional level more in terms of the frustration. I didn’t lock in on a grade. The kid grew. The kid got a B. I was actually really happy for him. Like, the stuff was growing and I went, okay, congratulations! You made all of our lives miserable, but you got something out of it.

So I don’t, I don’t find myself locking in on grades. Quite, quite the contrary. Like I said, this kid annoyed me. I was happy that the grade went up because, again, it meant something good happened in the room.

Boz: I, I just wanted to talk a little bit about the those two headings that you were talking about. First, the SBG is exhausting. Teaching is exhausting. I mean, there’s no two ways around that, but the SBG isn’t timely or accurate. I’m reading through that section. I get what they were saying. And yeah, I, I think it was either you Ashleigh or, or you Sharona, that was bringing up when I’m reading through this, it sounds more like an architecture issue.

That last decision of how do you take the collection of learning targets and their levels of proficiency on those learning targets and wrap it up to a final grade. And it seems like whatever method this author was using didn’t have a lot of completeness until the very end.

And it made me think about, the work you and I did together, Joe, last summer, we’re trying to make that, that grade tracker for your students. And I know Sharona, you and I are planning on having an episode specifically talking about grade tracking. But that’s, reading that, that seems like more of an architect issue than just an SBG or any kind of alternative grading.

So I would be curious if we could get this author on and learn a little bit more about how he did their wrap up because I, yeah, I think it’s when I read it, it seemed more of an issue there than actually with standards based grading itself.

Sharona: And one of the things I’m really struggling with right now is any form of alternative grading, when you say it is this, or it isn’t that. For example, this pilot that we just did in this traditional grading system in the course that I am coordinating, it had points and percentages, but when you dug under the hood, the teachers who were doing it are people I’ve been training for six years who agreed to do this because they are adjuncts whose jobs essentially are under threat.

So there was no way when the department chair came to them and said the deans want to do this, what are they going to say? Of course, right? So to their credit, they took our standards based graded system and they tried to do the least damage to slap points on it. Well, okay, there were points, but they still had some retakes, they still had feedback, it was still standards aligned.

So was it truly a traditional points and percentages system with all of its? So as I’m asked to go and do this pilot, I’m in a little bit of a moral quandary because should I insist on a truly traditional? If you’re going to try to force me go back to points and percentages, should I make these this, or is this going to hurt future, like if I say, if I try to tell the administrators, hey, this thing that you thought was traditional really wasn’t, it was really, you know, standards based.

So this whole what is and what isn’t these things, I think sometimes gets in our way. There’s so many, when you say the word standards based grading to someone who hasn’t done the deep work that we’ve all done. It just comes with a host of assumptions. And so that’s, I think one reason I am pushing back on it anyway.

Joe: I just think for you, the problem is if, if the goal is to determine which is better for students, then you need to make sure those toxic practices are still practiced. Because again, otherwise, and.

Sharona: That’s my moral quandary because now I’m going to take hundreds of students and actively hurt them for a semester in ways that could affect their lives for the rest of their lives.

Because my course is known as one of the reasons that students don’t stay in college. Okay, we’re talking about for the purposes of science. Allowing what, 20, 30, 40, a hundred students to not earn a million dollars in their lives and stay in poverty and intergenerational poverty because? You know, and so I probably can’t do that, but it’s just super hard.

Joe: And I’ll say it so you don’t have to. I would argue that there’s no science in it. It’s already been determined that these practices don’t work, so I don’t know why they’re asking to do it again, but that’s, that’s me.

Sharona: Because when, as a university faculty member, especially an adjunct, I am not allowed to speak directly to the administrators that are making these decisions. And I have to decide, and to my deans, if you’re listening to the podcast, which I hope some of you are, this is a union issue because it is probably a violation of our academic Senate rules. So we’re going to, we’re probably going to go down that route too. But again, I can’t force my faculty to not do this. And most of them don’t have the privilege that I personally have to be able to tell them where to go.

Joe: Oh, no, I know why you couldn’t. I was, I was saying, I can’t understand why a thoughtful administrator would need to see new research on something that’s been long settled.

Sharona: Well, but you said the keyword thoughtful.

Joe: Correct.

Sharona: And if I can’t get in front of them to convince them to start thinking, then that doesn’t happen. Now, that being said, though, I do want to move on to the next header because this one I am more conflicted about. So the next header in the article says standards based grading perpetuates the idea of a single standard.

And many mathematicians I would talk to, especially in the alt grading world will actually very much dispute that there is a single right way to do a lot of mathematics. There may be a single skill like addition in a common system, which you may have, the equivalent of that would be spelling in a, like, if you’re like, we’re working in standard academic English and you say that, and they need to be spelled a certain way.

But in mathematics, there’s actually a lot of creativity and beauty that could come out. So what do you think about this idea about there being a single standard being inherent to standards based grading.

Boz: I mean, we’ve, that’s what we were talking about at the very beginning of of this episode was, this single, especially in writing in English, this single correct American standard dialect.

Joe: I mean, it depends on, it depends on how you score. So like, at some point I would love to dig into this even more deeply. And Ashleigh, again, that whenever you want to chat, I would love to chat. But I, my, my learning targets, some of them are process based, which would fly in the face of product based, right?

But my point is, I need to see you doing the process, which means if it’s close reading, I need to see you using cognitive strategies. I don’t care which ones. I don’t care which order, but I want to see how you’re getting to comprehension, so if I can make sure that’s happening, comprehension will take care of itself.

So again, not a single standard. I don’t tell the kids what the text means, ever. All I need is them to arrive at something they can support with evidence, which means again, not a single standard. And then for grammar, and Bosley knows this, it, I have one explicitly writing based standard, and it’s writing skill and conventions.

Conventions are by far the most limited of it. And I use sort of the state testing, the West Coast Consortium, the Smarter Balanced Standard, which is again, if I can understand what you’re trying to tell me, Good. And then beyond that, we can talk about playing with style. So I try to limit that as much as possible.

So I just, I, again, part of this is what English teachers have traditionally done. The other part of it is if I’m teaching you how to shoot a basketball, shooting a basketball, I mean, the ball’s got to go in, right? So, I think there’s a push and pull. It can’t just be whatever, but I, as an English teacher, there’s a lot of right answers.

There’s some that are wrong, but there’s a lot of right answers. So it’s very, very few. I needed to look this way other than a structured essay needs to be a structured essay.

Ashleigh: Great. Just connecting to what you said, Sharona, about the beauty and creativity in mathematics that is so dominant in our field as well.

And when we focus on that, I would just call it low hanging fruit, like your MLA format and comma usage. Again, if the comma usage is not changing, or hiding the meaning, then maybe that’s not something to really, really, that’s not the hill that we need to die on. But, again, folks have graded in that way because it is so overwhelming to grade all of the aspects of an essay.

And, so it is just easier to find the things that are black and white. And can be measured by a single standard. But yeah, I mean I’m really convinced by the piece of this article that talks about the problematic nature of just that single standard. We can hold students to super high standards and still not have that really limited focus that eliminates the beauty and the creativity.

Joe: I would just say to just to build on what Ashleigh just said. That’s a problem for English teachers regardless of grading system. Traditional grading perpetuates this as well. I had a student, one of my favorite stories, Bosley, that we, that we had a few years ago.

This student was pushing hard to grow their writing and the process of growing their writing, they developed a massive comma splice problem. I got A’s in college papers with comma splices. A comma splice, for those of you who don’t know, is just a run on sentence where you’re connecting two sentences that should have a period with a comma.

So there’s just two complete sentences that come to. Who cares? The kid, and by the way, the kid then aced the AP test. So this comma splice issue was just a product of all the new thinking and how quick their brain was working. I didn’t penalize their grade. So I, you know what I mean? I just think that’s something that we have a lot of issues with English teachers doing what was done to them and going with that.

I do grade MLA format, but it’s part of a learning target that includes a structured essay that includes introducing your quotes so we understand it. writing in a way that actually builds to a thesis. So again, I minimize the MLA part. It’s one part of it. And if the MLA is the only thing getting them, it’ll be a, just go fix it. You know what I mean? And that’s it. So I just think that’s something, I don’t know, at least for, this is an English teacher as well. So I think we could argue to Chiaravelli that the issue is that’s a problem with all of us in English that a lot of people really drill into that. This is the one right way.

Sharona: Well, and as as a mathematician part of what I think is going on is that people who are less comfortable with mathematics are less comfortable redefining the idea of measurement. So I actually have a learning outcome, I don’t call them standards anymore, I call them learning outcomes. These are the things I want my students to come out with. They’re not my standards. I just, they’re the things I want them to come out with, but you can measure them in many different ways. And one of those measurements that I don’t see a lot of, and yet we know is motivational, is the gamification, the accumulation of evidence.

So like when you play these stupid games on your phone, which I am like hugely addicted to, to be clear. My kids tease me all the time that if there’s a version that even smacks of being similar to Candy Crush, I have it. But I do thousands of levels on these things for no reason other than points and coins and things that accumulate that have no value.

And I argue that just having students do certain things in and of itself can be valuable. Just do the thing. So why can’t we measure it by counting how many times they do the thing? And that once you’ve done enough of the things that’s like crossing a bar, that’s succeeding at a level. And we know that human beings respond to that kind of gamification.

But if we’re going to do that, we need to rethink what it is we’re measuring. And in my case, I’m literally measuring are you doing stuff that’s going to make you better at this thing? Whether you do it well or poorly, I don’t care. Are you just doing it? And so can we get more sophisticated about what we mean by measurement?

Could we measure, someone brings in a prompt or, or a, or a response to something and, you know, something happens in the classroom that we think is remarkable. Could that be a measurement? Like, I don’t know, but I just think that we need to be clearer. And I think part of it also is we need to say sometimes just doing stuff is what’s important, and if we want student to do stuff, we need to tell him we want them to do it.

And maybe it becomes part of the grade, not behaviorally, because I don’t agree with do it all the time, or do it 100 percent whatever, but do it enough, whatever that means.

Joe: So that’s how I do my reflections. And that’s the thing that drives my kids nuts, because they write a bunch of reflections, I don’t score every single one because I don’t have time, but they need to think about it. And again, doing it is what matters. And all I’m looking for is genuine thinking, genuine metacognition. I don’t care what their conclusion is. I care that they’re working it over. So that does count for something. So I certainly, I certainly agree with agree with that.

And I also just my reminder was in college in a physics class. I came up with the wrong answer on this problem. And I went and showed the teacher and I went, “I did it. One of the two ways you told me.” And he went and tried the second way and came up with my answer. And I watched him change my grade.

The whole point is there isn’t one right way to do it. And it turned out that the two ways he thought were identical were not. He checked my work, right? I mean, again, that’s the whole idea. That you’re just, you’re, you’re working the process. So I, I think there’s, there’s some real good ideas in there.

Boz: Well, we are coming up on our time.

So I did want to end on a note that I absolutely agree with this author. And unfortunately I just lost my extra monitors. So if someone else has this actual article pulled up, if you can read that last paragraph, cause this. I have it in my notes.

Sharona: The last one of the whole article?

Boz: Yeah.

Sharona: So it says, “but if standard based grading is to progress beyond the real difficulties that beset it, it must espouse curiosity over defensiveness, openness over dogmatism. Empathy over insularity. What becomes of standards based grading, whether it’s able to evolve or ossifies into irrelevance remains to be seen.”

And it’s really good that I read that and not you.

Joe: Yes.

Boz: But, but to this point, to this author’s point, and I think Sharona, you were talking about this earlier getting past this of a rigid definitions of, you know, what is SBG, what is ungrading? What is, you know, so getting past that rigid and the defensiveness of arguing, Oh no, if you’re not doing it this way, it’s not that, which by the way, I’ve been accused of doing in fact, the last time we critiqued an article, I got called out by one of our listeners for doing it.

But yeah. That part of this, I could not agree with more, and I think this is an excellent point, and I think this is a point that the reason the author was writing this to bring this up, so.

Ashleigh: I mean, I think this is an important reminder to all of us in the alt grading community that we do need to exercise the same kind of patience that we try to show to our students needs to extend to all of our colleagues.

And yeah, we’ve all had really, I would even say mean, pushback that attacks our character in addition to our practices. But, but just understanding that we will not, we will not help our cause by acting as though we have all the answers or that there is one correct way to do this. Because we all know that this is an evolution.

So, so I think my takeaway from that paragraph is just to remain patient, remain vigilant. I still want to walk the walk and talk the talk about all the good work that we can do here. But we really do need to shy away from this practice of criticizing others’ approaches. That’s it’s tempting and we need to not do it.

Joe: I think the framing of the first paragraph where he talks about again, he starts by pulling us all right to his side with I don’t want to go back to those toxic practices of the past. I think that’s dead on and this is dead on right that we’re trying to figure out the best way of a practice that most of us have come to with no training . That our profession, shamefully, has never really thought meaningfully about, now we’re thinking meaningfully about it, and, and I think he’s right, going to dogmatism when we’re still, you know, building this plane in midair. Would be the worst thing we could possibly do. So, and also, by the way, I keep saying, I keep saying Chiaravelli, it’s Chiaravalli.

So I just want to make sure as an Italian, I don’t massacre his name anymore. But I love that framing the beginning and the end. I agree, Sharona and Bosley. I think that’s great. And I, and I think the conversation starter is fantastic. I just think some of this stuff where Ashleigh and I, and Chiaravalli could have interesting conversations.

Some of this stuff is really just baked into the cake of language arts instruction that will transcend alternative grading, traditional and alternative grading will have these problems for language teachers.

Boz: That’s a good point. Yeah. And that’s part of the reason we wanted to have you guys here.

Cause we know the contextual differences between our areas of specialty, Sharona and the authors and your guys’s. There really is a big contextual difference that we just couldn’t address in an honest way without bringing in some of our favorite English people.

So thank you guys both for coming. It’s always a pleasure to talk with either of you, but having you both on at the same time has been great. Sharona, is there any last minute Ideas or are comments that you wanted to close on.

Sharona: Just that I really wish we were recording a two hour episode instead of a one hour episode because I’m not done with this conversation, but I know that we have to end. So thank you so much, Joe and Ashleigh. And we really look forward to having you guys back on because this is not the end of it.

Ashleigh: Thank you so much. Joe, so good to meet you.

Joe: Right back at you. This has been a good time. I hope we could do a part two.

Boz: All right. And thank you all for listening and we’ll see you next time.

Sharona: Please share your thoughts and comments about this episode by commenting on this episode’s page on our website http://www.TheGradingPod.Com. Or you can share with us publicly on Twitter, Facebook, or Instagram. If you would like to suggest a future topic for the show or would like to be considered as a potential guest for the show, please use the contact us form on our website.

The Grading Podcast is created and produced by Robert Bosley and Sharona Krinsky. The full transcript of this episode is available on our website.

Boz: The views expressed here are those of the host and our guest. These views are not necessarily endorsed by the Cal State System or by the Los Angeles Unified School District.

Leave a Reply