A common pushback that practitioners of alternative grading get is that students “don’t know how they are doing”. In this episode, Sharona and Bosley take a hard look at progress tracking and communicating progress to students. We include a variety of examples of progress trackers provided by several different alternative graders and talk about the ways in which progress tracking is important, regardless of the grading system in use.
Links
Please note – any books linked here are likely Amazon Associates links. Clicking on them and purchasing through them helps support the show. Thanks for your support!
Progress Trackers
- Tracking Mastery Worksheet Math 1090
- Example of MTH 210 Grade Record sheet W23
- Example of 85-310 grades checklist – spring 2024, by Abigail Noyce
- EGI Grade Check_Zeccola AP Lang, by Joe Zeccola and Robert Bosley
- Example CS 120 Learner progress tracker, by Dave Largent
- Sample Grade Sheet – by Abby Noble
Other Resources Mentioned in the Episode
- TED Talk: The Beauty of Data Visualization, David McCandless
- Getting Started Part 5: How to Determine When a Student has Completed a Learning Outcome and How to Roll it All Up Into a Final Grade
- Episode 48 – Implementation Challenges and Opportunities: A Conversation with Becky Peppler and Don Smith on Working with K-12 School Districts to implement Alternative Grading
- How to make and use grade trackers, Grading for Growth Blog, by David Clark
Resources
The Grading Conference – an annual, online conference exploring Alternative Grading in Higher Education & K-12.
Some great resources to educate yourself about Alternative Grading:
Recommended Books on Alternative Grading (Please note – any books linked here are likely Amazon Associates links. Purchasing through them helps support the show. Thanks for your support!):
- Grading for Growth, by Robert Talbert and David Clark
- Specifications Grading, by Linda Nilsen
- Undoing the Grade, by Jesse Stommel
- Grading for Equity, by Joe Feldman
The Grading Podcast publishes every week on Tuesday at 4 AM Pacific time, so be sure to subscribe and get notified of each new episode. You can follow us on Twitter, Facebook and Instagram – @thegradingpod. To leave us a comment, please go to our website: http://www.thegradingpod.com and leave a comment on this episode’s page.
If you would like to be considered to be a guest on this show, please reach out using the Contact Us form on our website, www.thegradingpod.com.
All content of this podcast and website are solely the opinions of the hosts and guests and do not necessarily represent the views of California State University Los Angeles or the Los Angeles Unified School District.
Music
Country Rock performed by Lite Saturation
Country Rock by Lite Saturation is licensed under a Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.
Transcript
52 – grade tracker
===
Sharona: And so what comes up in focus groups all the time is that they’re very unhappy that they don’t know how they’re doing.
Boz: So, I want to push back on that statement just a little bit because you keep saying most, I have seen no evidence whatsoever that it is most students. It is definitely some, but I, until someone can actually show me the percentages and the data. I push back on this idea of most students.
Welcome to the Grading Podcast, where we’ll take a critical lens to the methods of assessing students learning, from traditional grading to alternative methods of grading. We’ll look at how grades impact our classrooms and our students success. I’m Robert Bosley, a high school math teacher, instructional coach, intervention specialist, and educator. And instructional designer in the Los Angeles Unified School District and with Cal State LA.
Sharona: And I’m Sharona Krinsky, a math instructor at Cal State Los Angeles, faculty coach, and instructional designer. Whether you work in higher ed or K 12, whatever your discipline is, whether you are a teacher, a coach, or an administrator, this podcast is for you. Each week, you will get the practical, detailed information you need to be able to actually implement effective grading practices in your class and at your institution.
Boz: Hello, and welcome back to the podcast. I’m Robert Bosley, one of your two co hosts, and with me as always, Sharona Krinsky. How are you doing today, Sharona?
Sharona: I’m doing well. At the time of this recording, we are in the middle of June gloom in California, which this year has started in April. And I don’t think this episode is going to come out for a while, but for those of you that don’t live in California, June gloom is when the entire sky is absolute light gray, no variation. And then it burns off later in the day. And I’m just looking at my window going, that is a gloomy June gloom. So I’m trying not to be taken down by the June gloom out my window. How about you?
Boz: Well, like you said, at the time of this recording, which I think we might want to explain, cause we’ve been saying that for a little bit, but you and I both have travel plans during the summer. I’m taking a very long road trip back home to see family and stuff. So we’ve been recording a lot of episodes so we can, you know, release them throughout our break. But at the time of we recording, this is my first official day of summer break. Like my school just officially ended yesterday. So, Hey, Why not get up at nine o’clock in the morning and record a podcast on my first day of summer break, right?
Sharona: Well, and again, since we’re admitting when we’re recording this, what are we working on today other than recording the podcast?
Boz: Oh, yeah. At the time of this recording, the fifth annual grading conference is less than 24 hours away. Now, by the time this comes out, it would have been over for a while, but yeah, we’re less than 24 hours to our countdown to our biggest conference yet.
Sharona: So I’m excited by that. I’m excited to record this episode. You know, life, I was just talking to a friend and life feels really big right now. I’ve got lots of really good things going on, lots of really challenging things going on. But scarily enough, talking about grades makes me happy. So I don’t know what that says about me.
Boz: Yeah, we’re both a little crazy, I think, but this is one of the things that, that is always enjoyable, regardless of how busy or stressed everything else is.
Sharona: Exactly, so we don’t have any guests in the studio today. So what are we talking about?
Boz: So we’re actually going to be looking at a topic that you especially have been getting a lot of questions and pushbacks on. And that pushback is students don’t know how they’re doing in an ungraded class because they don’t have, you know, a, running average that can be calculated at any time that supposedly tells them what their grade is. So we’re going to be.
Sharona: Quick correction. You said ungraded. You meant alternatively graded, I believe.
Boz: I did? See? You got me talking about ungrading.
Sharona: Exactly. So we are going to talk about it and ungrading, but we’re actually going to talk about it first in any alternatively graded class, particularly specifications and standards.
So.
Boz: So can you go into a little bit more detail about this pushback or this concern that has been brought up by different groups of people about the students understanding what their grades are.
Sharona: So yes, absolutely and one of the challenges that our community will understand is this pushback is coming from, to a large degree, many people who don’t understand how grades really function versus how they think they function. So both students and people who are not in our grading reform world truly believe in grades as motivation, and in grades as the ability to control behavior.
So if we assume for a moment that’s true, which I dispute, but if you do, then the importance of students knowing where they stand becomes of heightened importance, right? So in the bigger world, when a student is asked in a focus group, how they feel about an alternatively graded class. Many of them will say how stressful it is that they don’t know how they’re doing because these students are in the process of transitioning many of them from 12 or 13 or 14 years of grades as a system of motivation and behavior into what we’re trying to accomplish, which is taking the grades away so we can focus on learning, but many students are not there yet. And so what comes up in focus groups all the time is that they’re very unhappy that they don’t know how they’re doing.
Boz: So I want to push back on that statement just a little bit, because you keep saying most, I have seen no evidence whatsoever that it is most students. It is definitely some, but I, until someone can actually show me the percentages and the data. I push back on this idea of most students.
Sharona: Most students what? Which part did I say?
Boz: That most students don’t understand and are stressed because they don’t know what their grades are.
Sharona: I would agree. What I would say is the people who are coming to speak to me are the ones saying that most students don’t. Which I, I agree with you. I dispute because focus groups are not indicative. And when you’re specifically asked to talk about something you don’t normally think about, because students really think far less about the structure of a grading system, they may think a lot about what grade they’re getting, but they don’t necessarily think too hard about the grading system, but they want to know. And, and this is what they say in focus groups. So the people who are coming to me with pushback against grading reform is one group of people who are saying students don’t know how they’re doing. I would also say that I see in my own classes, those students who don’t understand quickly how this is working are also struggling to understand. So I, I am hearing from a lot of grading practitioners, grading alternative grading practitioners that they are struggling to tell their students how they’re doing. So this is coming up both from people pushing back, but also people within the community who want to communicate to their students how they’re doing.
Boz: And we talked a lot about this in our getting buy in episode about, you know, the students can’t, not just won’t, but can’t buy into a grading system that they don’t understand. So I do agree with, you know, the students, absolutely needing to understand your grading architecture. And yes, most of my students at the beginning do struggle with that. And that’s largely because, you know, the first time I might have them. Is their senior year of high school or their freshman year of college and both of those, you know, they’ve had a decade or more of traditional grading. So yes, it takes some time and it might be stressful for them at the beginning, but most of my students by midway through a first semester, if not before, you know, do understand the grading system and do are able to calculate their grades. I’ve not had as much of a concern from students personally.
And again, this is just me personally. This is not any kind of data to back up, but after the first, you know, five, six weeks, if that, I don’t get much pushback or concern from my students. It’s other adults that I see it from, whether it’s the student’s parents . , if we’re talking high school, my counselors, my admin. It’s other adults that seem to have a more of an issue with this than my students do.
Sharona: I think that is also largely driven by, and I saw some articles about this recently, by the fact that there’s a lot more visibility because of these electronic grade books and these, whether it’s Canvas or Schoology, that many more stakeholders have direct access to the details of a grade book, or at least they think they do. They think they have visibility. So because the vast majority of the world is so bought into 90%, 80%, 70%, 60% determines your grade, they’re very comforted when they can log into a computer system and look at a very simple thing that says this student currently has 72%. They’re like, great, the student’s passing.
We know, both as mathematicians and as instructors, just how false those interim marks in a gradebook are. We understand that most of the gradebooks are only looking at categories that have already had some grades in them. So the weighting is completely off throughout the semester. Most of the grade books that I see, they’re just false information and yet that’s what I hear is, but anyone can look at it and know what it means.
Boz: I think I’ve told this story on the podcast before, I actually had an experience this year with my oldest daughter who just completed her junior year of high school. where just that happened. You know, she had been, and this was at her math class and she, you know, been doing really well. Well she went from an A to an F overnight. Why? Because they took their very first test and that A that she, you know, the, 93 percent or whatever it was that she had because the test was 70 percent of her grade. And because this was the first test and she was going to have chances to revise it, but hadn’t had the chances yet that first test that she did not do as well as she thought she was going to do on it. You know, did it dropped her from an A to an F overnight and it destroyed her. I mean, she was devastated when she saw that and she still had other categories that they hadn’t used at all.
So, you know, the way the weights are in these LMS systems were set up, most of them will redistribute the weight of a category that hasn’t been used. So that test wasn’t just 70 percent because there were other categories like projects that hadn’t been done yet. That test was actually more than even 70 percent of her current grade.
Sharona: I think that this idea of progress tracking is probably more fundamental than we realize in terms of learning, because if you look at a lot of the apps that you do, and a lot of the games that you play, you know, I’m on Duolingo, for example. I’ve been practicing my Hebrew, and I’ve studied Hebrew most of my life, but from the perspective of a American student who’s not in a day school that uses the language, and I just decided that I wanted to start learning this language, and there’s all kinds of progress trackers.
Now, I’m not getting a grade, for this class, there are no grades. I am on Duolingo and I’m doing it for fun and they have all these different gamification things. But there’s a lot of progress tracking. And there’s progress tracking in Candy Crush and there’s progress tracking in Call of Duty. And like there’s progress tracking everywhere and it can be motivational and it can be reassuring and it can be fun. And I think that people like to know like to be able to see how far they’ve come. So I do think that there are positive sides to progress tracking.
Boz: Alright, so, we’ve kind of set up the issue with the problem is students being able to, or not just students, but people other than the professor, being able to track and understanding where grades. are. So you mentioned this progress tracker. That’s kind of the term that we use for anything that can display and help show and track the students goals or pathways to achieving the final grades that they want to get. Now, yes, LMS systems are a grade tracker of sort. However, what we’ve discovered is most of the LMS systems that we’re familiar with, that we’ve talked to other people that have used don’t necessarily have great mastery, and I’m using that word because that’s what most of the LMS systems use, don’t have good mastery tracking grade books. Like I use Schoology and Canvas. Both of them have one. I use both of them. The canvas one is better, but it’s still not the easiest thing, and it’s not as clear as a gradebook that uses points and percentages and gives you that final, “you currently have an 83. 4%.”
Sharona: Yeah, it doesn’t clearly lie to you the way the percentage based gradebook does.
Boz: Yeah.
Sharona: It lies to you in ways that are difficult to understand.
Boz: What can we do to address this?
Sharona: Well, I’m really proud because I want to say this is the first episode, I think I’ve really crowdsourced some of the materials. So those of you on the alternative grading Slack channel, I posted this in the channel a while back, and I want to thank some people who sent us things. I’m not going to name them cause I didn’t, I don’t know if I specifically have permission for their names. But there were quite a few people who, you know, who you are, who contributed. their take on how you do progress tracking. So we’re going to link all these in the show notes and we’re going to talk in compare and contrast a variety of progress checkers. For me, they seem to fall into a couple of main categories.
One of those main categories is the format in which they’re delivered. So one person I know I can mention is Stephen Clontz. He’s not one of the ones who did this particular thing, so none of the grade trackers we’re going to look at are his. But he said that he started with actually a web application that he wrote, because he’s well known within our community for web applications. He went away from that because he decided it wasn’t sustainable. So one option is possibly a web based app. I don’t know anyone currently doing that, but if you are doing a web based application, please feel free to send it to us. But the other two categories really are paper based and technology based.
Boz: And when we say technology based, what’s the difference between technology based and web based? Like, what’s the distinction that you’re making here?
Sharona: So a web application, in my mind, is actually using coding, actual coding behind the scenes. Whereas technology based, I’m thinking of, they’re primarily Google Sheets or Excel spreadsheets. Or some other like package thing. But it’s basically on a, it’s an overlay of some sort of a data application. And usually it’s in some sort of a shareable form that students can interact with. So maybe a better way of making the distinction might be interactive versus non interactive. Interactive being in addition to a student putting stuff in or an instructor putting stuff in other things happen. Whereas non interactive is you might be making marks on a paper. But you have to do everything from that point to see where.
e tracking in our common math:, it’s going to say like math:Boz: And this can, because it is a Google Doc, you can use this one with your students either as a Google Doc or as a printed copy, which is what I usually do. I usually print these out and give them to my students and have them fill out as we go. Although I do think that’s something you and I have been talking about, maybe revising and making this a little bit more robust and interactive with our students next semester. But yeah, that’s what we currently have. Like I said, I do paper versions. Do you do paper versions or like?
Sharona: Yeah, I do. I do paper versions. So this is so far it’s been entirely paper. I really think one of the primary things I do want to do this. semester is to make it into an interactive one. But basically it’s a series of check boxes or boxes they can check. And so the first Look at it as students get is a calendar based one, and they can use that where they literally just write a check if they are successful on the assessment that week for that thing, and when they get two checks in a row in a single row on the table, they put a check at the end, and that’s it.
Actually, I guess they don’t really check on the first page. They more do the checks on the second page. So the second page is a look at the same material. It’s a list of all the learning outcomes and it’s a list of the assessments across the top. And when they’re successful, they check the box and when they get two checks in a single row, they check the box at the end and then they just count those ones at the end.
Boz: Yeah, because we have a very simplistic grading architecture for both our decisions three and four, which if you’re not sure what those are definitely want to go back to our, one of our first getting started series grading architecture, but yeah, our decisions three and four are very simple simple in, in times and a simple count.
We do use color. And we’re going to talk a little bit more about color later, but we’ve used color to indicate the different chances. So the first chance is green. The second chance is yellow. The third chance is blue. So students can see where they’re progressing through.
So that’s, that’s ours now.
Sharona: Well, and then I would talk for a moment about how I use this. So we print it out, I usually print it out right after the first assessment on the first standard. And then I’m not as good as I’d like, I’m intending to get better, of telling them multiple times through the semester to pull it out and update it. So I’m finding that students are not using it as much as I want them to because I’m not training them enough to use it.
ferences between when I teach:So in my:Sharona: I also wanted to insert a comment here that our course is standards based. We’re going to talk about a variety of these process progress trackers, most of which are, progress trackers, most of which are either from standards based courses or specifications based courses or some combination of those. We will talk after we get through these about progress tracking in an ungraded course briefly as well. So we’re not going to ignore the ungraders out there, but understand that these progress trackers initially that we’re talking about are primarily standards or specifications or some combination of both. So what’s the second one we’re going to talk about?
Boz: So, another one that is very similar to ours which is an example from a Math 210 course, which will also be linked, is another one that looks like a printed version very similar to ours, except because they have a more complex grading architecture, especially with the wrap up, that decision four. They have those kinds of scenarios on that tracker. So student knows, Oh, okay. To, to get a D I need to check off all these boxes. Once I’ve got all those checked off, I can start checking off the C’s and can see more about what they need in each of the different categories. So.
Sharona: Yeah, this is an intro. If you look at the okay, so if you look at the learning targets on math 210, this is an intro to proofs type course because it’s got logic and statements, numbers, sets, functions, examples. And so there is a lot of writing built into this course.
Boz: Which you’ll see, that writing you’ll see in the grading architecture because the mathematical writing is so important in this class. He doesn’t have a simplistic wrap up like we do in our stats class, but that shows up on the tracker. That shows up and so students can see, Oh, I, I might have enough learning targets done to get the B that I’m wanting, but I need more portfolio drafts. I need more of the writing check marks.
So this is something, the more complex, and we’re going to see this throughout looking at all these, the more complex your grading architecture is, the more complex your tracker is going to have to be for better or worse.
Sharona: And I think that the graphic design of these trackers ,actually, is pretty important. Because what we’re seeing is these grade trackers, or these grading architectures, can get very complex very quickly. And these grade trackers are an attempt to visualize the grading system and provide students with a road map.
Boz: I want to transition, but I want to make sure you’re through talking with this one about this one before I do. So with that being said, with the visualization being so important, I actually really like most of our other examples that we have, because they are interactive. These are all some form of spreadsheet. But one of the things that all three of these that we’re going to talk about have in common is the use of colors and conditional colors that actually change. I think this is so incredibly important and it’s very clear, very easy for the students to see and realize, and all of those color changes are built into it, which you don’t have to be a programmer to set this up in most spreadsheets. It’s takes a couple of commands, but not much.
Sharona: And that’s actually, reminds me there is a TED talk that I will link in the show notes that there’s more and more and more buzz about data visualization being important for conveying the meaning of information. And I think we’re seeing the interaction here that if we really want and believe that our grading architecture can actually promote learning and growth mindsets, there’s a lot of data visuals out there that can help that.
A metaphor that I use verbally, but I would maybe like to turn into part of my progress tracker, is I visualize the grading in my course as an accumulation of evidence of learning. And I often tell my students that we’re starting at the bottom of a mountain and people are going to climb the mountain at different points, and there’s going to be guideposts along the track, and there might be opportunities to take it to stop and look around and look at the beauty and all of that is going to help with their idea of I’m growing and continuing among along the journey of learning. And so I think that we have a ways to go, but that there are real opportunities here to use data visualization in our progress trackers.
Boz: Yeah. And like I said, with these interactive ones, color and conditional coloring is probably one of those easiest things to do to do that visualization. So do we want to get into some of these other examples that we have that are more interactive? Yeah.
Sharona: Yes, and I think if it’s okay with you, I’d like to go to the one that is 85 310.
Boz: Okay.
Sharona: So, this is a grade tracker that was provided by Abby Noyce, Abigail Noyce and she uses a combination of specs grading and bundles. And one of the things that I really like about this particular grade tracker is that it has two features that do exist on some of the other ones, but this is the first one I looked at, which is it does use the conditional color. So as you complete different parts of this spreadsheet, and it tells you what grade is currently computed, it changes the color of the grade box. Additionally, it has one other thing that, again, the other ones do as well. It has a section called, What do I still need to do to get a… and then it fills in the grade, an A, a B, a C, or a D. So this one has a lot of interactive features that I find very satisfying.
Boz: Yeah, so this one, just looking at the tracker, I’m going to say is probably the most complex grading architecture out of any of these that we’re looking at. But to help with that, you know, this tracker doesn’t, so one of the other things that all three trackers do is it will say the current grade. It will give the student that the current grade, like if the course was to end right now, this is what the grade you would have, but this one also has. What you need, how many elements from each of their components. So this one has six different components to their grading architecture. Which again and is fairly complex and anyone that’s starting off, please do not ever try to have six components in a grading architecture.
But this one tracks and will tell the student, okay, I might have a C right now, but I need to get that B. I need, you know, two more learning targets and one more of another category and to get the A, I need three more of these learning targets, one more of this category, one more of this category. So it’s very specific in telling the student exactly what they need. And again, the more complex your grading architecture is, the more important it is to have something like this on your trackers. Letting the students know exactly what they need to do.
Sharona: And so what we’re going to do is in the show notes, we’re going to put a link to view only versions of these, what you do, they’re all going to be Google Docs and Google Sheets for shareability, but you can make a copy using the file menu to make a copy of the sheet for yourself. And the minute you make a copy, everything unlocks and you can play with these yourself. So thank you to the people that contributed these copies. So I do, like the fact that this person, you, and this does not require a huge amount of computation. There’s no programming really behind it. It’s all using drop down menus and some conditional statements that are built into Google Docs, Google Sheets and Excel. There’s no actual coding, per se, behind this sheet. So you don’t need to know Python or, you know, R or SageMath or any of those things.
Boz: Yeah. Now you, you do have to have, you know, at least an intermediate level of understanding of spreadsheets with some, if then algorithms and some coloring conditions and stuff like that, but it, it’s not Python coding, it’s not SageMath coding, it’s not, you know, real high levels of spreadsheets even it’s, but you will need a, at least an intermediate, or you can also, because there’s so many of these on some of our resources in the slack community and so many of our other communities, it’s also, you can take them and modify them to fit your course, so you don’t have to start from scratch.
Sharona: Exactly. Exactly. And most of these examples that we’re going to give you, you can dive under the hood and copy and paste something from one of these and play with it to, to reverse engineer what’s being done as well.
Boz: Yeah and in fact, one of the other ones that we can jump to is the one that Joe Zeccola uses. And I am using his name cause I do have his permission to use his name on this. His tracker is one of the other ones that’s linked here. And. You know, here’s another way where he’s not as, you know, a high level user of Excel, but he knows what’s possible. So, you know, he came to me and said, Hey, this is what I want it to do. We work together. We got it to, to work, but once I had put it together, he’s now gotten almost every single alternative grader at his school using this tracker and none of them is identical like once it’s there, they can go in and modify a few easy places to make their tracker fit their class. Because even though they’re all at the same school and are teaching using some similar structures, they don’t have the exact same grading architecture. So. You know, it’s a science teacher might have a couple more learning targets or a couple of less, or, you know, might want a smaller percentage of learning targets to get the certain grades. So once it’s built, it’s very easy to modify.
Sharona: So I’d like to compare and contrast a little bit the 85 310 that we just talked about and Joe’s, which is the EGI one. So on the 85 310, it. lays out the different things with some references that someone taking the course would understand. So it might list the learning targets as learning target one, two, three, four. And it has some milestones for research projects labeled 2.1, 2.2, 2.3.
There’s no real information on that tracker about what those things are. And that’s something different from the one Joe uses. Joe actually has not only has his targets actually listed out on this progress tracker. And this is because I think in large part because of a very deep difference between his grading architecture and the one for 85 310. So 85 310 is one of those where students just check off what they’ve completed and the grade computes from it. Can you explain how Joe does his? So how does this differ from that?
Boz: Well, so, you know, one of the things that you said it does have the actual learning targets written out in this tracker but also has a more simplistic wrap up architecture that that decision for is much more simplistic compared to that one we were just talking about. But another thing that’s really unique, I think about this one when comparing. It also has all of a place to track all the single assignments within a learning target. And, the student themselves, will suggest what they think their proficiency score should be for that entire learning target.
Now, of course, students don’t get a hundred percent say on this. It’s a, once they propose it, you know Joe will either, will have a conference with them or communicate with them about, Hey, Why do you think this is the, you know, a three that this is not quite looking like a three to me or hey, why do you think this is a three you’re underrating yourself. This is actually much closer to a four. So they have, you know, the ability to propose. So that’s almost a ungrading kind of concept. And what’s really interesting about this one compared to the other two, even. Is this one can calculate the student’s grade based on the learning targets taught. So he might give this tracker at the very beginning. Well, some of these learning targets, he’s not going to get to until, you know, midway through the semester or even the second semester, because this is for a high school class. So his, you know, he teaches his class year round, not semester by semester.
So this has the ability to recalculate if a learning target has not yet been addressed. Which is something unique, you know, if you’re comparing that to the 85 310, has it done the source on research writing? Well, they can’t have proficiency yet in it, if they haven’t done it. And that’s still going to show up in that grade. So, a student, you know, couldn’t have an A in the class until that grade. Was actually done, which I think is something different about the one that Joe uses is if that proficiency score is scored as an N/A, meaning it has not been taught yet. It doesn’t affect the overall calculation of the grade.
Sharona: And that’s something that I wonder about because even with ours, with an interactive tracker, when something hasn’t been taught yet, it shows the student is getting an F. And it’s in ours, it’s going to show the student is getting enough for the first seven or eight weeks because it’s seven or eight weeks until we’ve assessed enough that even the best student could be passing the class. So maybe adding something to the tracker where you tell the tracker, is there enough information yet? Like what’s been completed? And maybe before that time, the tracker just says, well, you’ve gotten this out of what’s possible, but your grade is not yet calculatable. Because we haven’t done enough or something like that. Something to think about.
The other thing I like about Joe’s, about the EGI one, is that the explanation for the grading criteria is also present. So we’ve seen some of them that do it and some of them that don’t. So 85 310, you can infer what the criteria are because you can see what do I still need to get, you know, the what if scenario, but it’s not explicitly stated anywhere. Whereas on both the math 210 one and ours, and Joe’s, it does say, as a reminder, here’s your grading criteria.
Boz: With Joe’s, it doesn’t just do the grading criteria that decision for, you know, this is what you need for a, B, C, D, but at the other end of it, It actually also gives the meaning of the proficiency scales. Now it’s done in a general form, so it’s not, you know, his get more specific for each of his different learning targets, but it does give a general meaning to those proficiency scores. So the student know, Oh, I got a three, that means I’m demonstrating proficiency. I’ve met the learning target, or I’ve got a two. Almost there. You’re approaching the learning target. Keep going. So it gives some of those descriptors, which I think is unique. I didn’t see that on any of the others. I don’t see it on ours. But, that’s something that. might be nice to add to ours. Cause I think that is something that is helpful for the students.
Sharona: Math 210 has it at the bottom as well. It says marks. Yeah, it’s at the very bottom. So S is successful. Good work. Put a check. R is revisable. There’s a minor error that needs fixing and is a new attempt needed. There’s a major issue that needs work. So they do explain the marks in that one as well.
So that leads us to the last one that we have a physical example of and this is CS 120. This was given to us by Dave Largent. And this one has actually the most components. And I would say in a way, I believe that’s because a lot of the computer science classes I know use specifications more so if you look at the categories, the categories are exams, quizzes, activities and labs, expert of the day, mid semester self assessment, project pre submission, project zero to three, and the final project. So the work here is more, you have a thing, whether it’s a quiz, an exam, a project, whatever, and you need that whole item to get to a certain level. And. What I also like, so this one is based partially on what students have already accomplished, but then also has a what if section. So the student can record their actual situation. And then put in different what ifs to say, what if I got two more of this? What if I got 10 more points on this? What if I got this? What if I got that? How would that impact my grade?
Boz: And another component of this one that I really like, so that he also has the, you know, what do you need to get to get the next grade? So it has a place where a student can put their target grade, like, you know, maybe I’m shooting for a B or where it shows what they need to get to their target grade also has the minimum for the A. So it’s like, I don’t care what you’re going to put in there. I’m also going to show you what you need to get to an A because, and I know he has the same mentality as you and I do is we want our, like, we would love nothing more than to have every single student get an A. So I love the fact that it’s. That philosophy is shown in this tracker where, you know, I’m in a class I don’t think I’m very good in. So I might say, Oh, my target grade is a C. I’m still going to know what I need to get for that A.
Sharona: Exactly. I feel like this is the most complex of the trackers that we’ve seen. And I think it’s because the grading architecture is the most complex. So I would say that the more complex your architecture is, the more that you need some sort of a visual or interactive progress tracker so that students can do the computations. And what strikes me about this, Is in my opinion, traditional grading is just as complex as this. We just mask it from the students. We mask the calculations.
Boz: Yeah. Going back to that story I was telling you about with my daughter earlier this year, like I said, she was, when that happened, she was devastated. And you know, when I asked her what was going on, I mean, she was breaking down, bawling saying, dad, I promise I’m going to, I’m trying really hard. Like she was worried I was going to be disappointed in her. But when we started talking and she’s like, dad, I, you know, I’m going to, I promise I’ll keep doing all the homework. I’m going to, you know, keep working really hard on the homework and all this other stuff. And I’m like, sweetheart, doing all that homework is hopefully going to prepare you for the test, but it ain’t going to do anything for your grade. Cause you’re already at a hundred percent. In fact, the only thing the homework can do for your grade is make it go less if you get less than 100%.
So, the students just seeing that final number and going, Oh, that’s not good, and thinking, what can I do to get better? Oh, I’m going to do more homework. She was already doing all the homework. That actually mathematically was not going to help her grade. Again, hopefully doing the homework made her test better. But mathematical wise, it wasn’t doing anything. All it could do is actually make it go worse if she didn’t continue to be perfect on the homework. So yeah, you’re right. Because of all the math that’s involved with weighted averages and things like that, our students might be able to see the number and know what the letter is, They don’t have any more clue of how to move that scale than anything that, that we show is just, Oh, I know what that number means.
Sharona: And that brings to mind something that Becky Peppler said on an episode a couple of weeks ago, where she had that aha moment talking to a parent who came in without the student during parent teacher conference and says, I see that on the quiz for chapter one, my student didn’t do well, got like a 63%. What do I need to work with him on? Because obviously that chapter is going to come up. This is his first AP or something like that. I think it was AP chemistry. And the teacher had to look at the parent and say, let me get back to you. Because the teacher had no idea, the teacher had to go back and say, gosh, I hope the student still has that exam that I handed back to them because I need to look at that exam to find out what the student needs to do. So that number obscured it even from the teacher.
Boz: Yeah. Which if you guys haven’t listened to that episode yet, that was a really fun episode with Becky Peppler and Don Smith. But so before we start kind of wrapping up, cause it is. Getting close to that time. There is something else that is common from a technical standpoint on all of these that I want to point out because I don’t want someone to try to do this and make this mistake and it become a disaster. All three of these interactive spreadsheet examples have all of the math, all of the if then statements, all of the conditional things on a different tab that can be hidden and protected from the students. So the student can’t go in and mess up the formulas, mess up your algorithms, and then screw their tracker up accidentally. So that is a very important piece that if you’re going to try to make one of these, do all of those setups, all those conditional statements, all those if thans, do that on a different tab that then can be hidden and protected from, you know, students or anyone else, so they don’t accidentally break your, break your tracker.
Sharona: There is one more topic, actually, that we need to address before we can wrap up today, and that is what about in an ungraded class where a faculty member is only giving feedback and there are no marks, there’s no ones and zeros, no checks, no any of that? And neither of us are ungraders. Luckily, David Clark to the rescue on the grading for growth blog wrote an entire article about progress trackers that we will link in the show notes. But there’s one section about what if you have a gradeless class and his. opinion, which I agree with, although I not have not implemented personally, is that progress trackers are still very important.
Because in any form of a gradeless class where there is a final grade to be delivered, each instructor needs to decide how are they going to decide on the final grade. Some people have gone all the way to the end to say they just tell all the students that they should suggest A’s, that’s one way to do it, but if you want to have the students actually track their progress and understand, you need to probably be. Do the same thing you’re doing in the grades, which is it becomes more of a feedback style thing. So for example, he gives an example that in his Euclidean geometry class, one of the areas that they need to work on is triangle congruences. And they have to put together an argumentative portfolio by the end of the class to present to him to say, I have successfully gathered evidence of all the things that I’m supposed to gather evidence of for this class.
So his progress tracker names the thing that they need to gather evidence on and has them track which possible item of that they’re doing in the class, he calls it an artifact, could they use it to provide evidence? So throughout the class, as they do a problem or a theorem or something that relates to triangle congruence, they make a note on the progress tracker. Hey, the problem I did on this date or the number of the problem or the theorem, That’s someplace when I need to put my portfolio together, I’m going to go back and look to see if I’m satisfied with that evidence as the student. And then he has a section that says why it’s useful. So again, as the student is actually completing the problem, they’re reflecting on why this, what this is evidence of, and why it’s evidence of that. And do they need to revise it?
Boz: Yeah. And, you know, I don’t know if you’ve ever had to, I’ve had to do a couple of different professional or educational portfolios and it’s the same thing there. You know I didn’t get grades. I got some feedback, but I didn’t get grades on all of these portfolio elements, but I did have, you know, a checklist of, okay, I need so many items of artifacts or of evidence to show proficiency in this thing. And then in this one, and then this one. So yeah, even if it’s something as simple as that kind of check sheet just so, you know, the student knows at the end these are the things I need to present But yeah again you and I neither of us have ever attempted to do ungrading. I don’t think either of us are thinking about doing ungrading yet. I know your math history class might get there at some point but yeah, please go read that blog. It’s a, it’s a great post. If you are an ungrader and also are seeing issues with tracking or want to see how you might be able to help your students, it very well could be with the tracking part.
Sharona: Well, and I would argue thinking about it, I’m going to give an example of a portfolio that I think every university faculty member is going to understand the minute I say it. And then everyone else will give a different version, but so for every university faculty, I’m going to talk about your evaluation or RTP binder, where you’re told gather evidence according to certain criteria from the last number of years to be evaluated for review and promotion. And then anyone who ever has a job anywhere, any, that is not just show up on time or punch a clock. Often we have to provide evidence. What have you done? And, you know, so this is actually a very real world thing, is teaching students how to track their own work, evaluate it, and prepare it for presentation. So this might be one of the most important things an ungraded class could do. Is teach the skill.
Boz: Alright, well, we are coming up on time. I hope you guys enjoyed this. I hope you guys do check out some of these trackers because I do think it is incredibly important, not just for our students, but also for a lot of the pushback that you might be getting from parents, colleagues or admin. Wish us luck for the conference and we’ll see you next week.
Sharona: Please share your thoughts and comments about this episode by commenting on this episode’s page on our website, www. thegradingpod. com. Or you can share with us publicly on Twitter, Facebook, or Instagram. If you would like to suggest a future topic for the show or would like to be considered as a potential guest for the show, please use the contact us form on our website. The Grading Podcast is created and produced by Robert Bosley and Sharona Krinsky. The full transcript is available on our website
Boz: The views expressed here are those of the host and our guest. These views are not necessarily endorsed by the Cal State system or by the Los Angeles Unified School District.

Leave a Reply