In this episode Sharona and Bosley reflect on one year of The Grading Podcast. From memorable moments and guests to
Links
Please note – any books linked here are likely Amazon Associates links. Clicking on them and purchasing through them helps support the show. Thanks for your support!
Grading Podcast Episodes mentioned in this episode (in the order they are mentioned):
- 6 – The Anatomy of a Learning Outcome: An Interview with Joe Zeccola
- 13 – Interim Grades: What do we do when we have to report “grades” in the middle of a term? With Joe Zeccola
- 39 – Systemic Change – A Look at how Los Angeles Unified School District developed their new grading policy, based on Equitable Grading practices. With Joe Zeccola
- 33 – An Interview with Dr. Thomas Guskey: A Journey through the History of Grading Reform Efforts
- 4 – Grading for Growth: An Interview with Robert Talbert
- 38 – Twenty+ Small Steps to Get Started with Alt Grading (Inspired by the recent blog post at Grading for Growth)
- 18 – The Sportscaster of Alternative Grading: An Interview with Matt Townsley
- 46 – Extinguishing the Fires within Assessment and Grading Reform: Welcoming Back Dr. Matt Townsley
- 42 – Metacognition, Power Structures in the Classroom, what is reasonable to expect of students? An Interview with Dr. Theresa Gaines.
- 36 – Teaching More by Grading Less (or Differently) – an Interview with Jeff Schinske, 10 years later
- 32 – Active Learning and Alternative Grading: When Intentional Pedagogy and Intentional Assessment Truly Align
- 31 -The Role of “Effort” or “Work” in an Alternative Grading Architecture and the Relationship with Due Dates
- 44 – Artificial Intelligence And Alt Grading: Challenges and Opportunities
Resources
The Grading Conference – an annual, online conference exploring Alternative Grading in Higher Education & K-12.
Some great resources to educate yourself about Alternative Grading:
Recommended Books on Alternative Grading (Please note – any books linked here are likely Amazon Associates links. Purchasing through them helps support the show. Thanks for your support!):
- Grading for Growth, by Robert Talbert and David Clark
- Specifications Grading, by Linda Nilsen
- Undoing the Grade, by Jesse Stommel
- Grading for Equity, by Joe Feldman
The Grading Podcast publishes every week on Tuesday at 4 AM Pacific time, so be sure to subscribe and get notified of each new episode. You can follow us on Twitter, Facebook and Instagram – @thegradingpod. To leave us a comment, please go to our website: http://www.thegradingpod.com and leave a comment on this episode’s page.
If you would like to be considered to be a guest on this show, please reach out using the Contact Us form on our website, www.thegradingpod.com.
All content of this podcast and website are solely the opinions of the hosts and guests and do not necessarily represent the views of California State University Los Angeles or the Los Angeles Unified School District.
Music
Country Rock performed by Lite Saturation
Country Rock by Lite Saturation is licensed under a Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.
Transcript
53 – oneyear
===
Sharona: I’m really shocked at actually how big this community is. I mean, I know the grading conference has grown year over year over year and that’s spectacular, but not everybody listens to podcasts. So some of the statistics just to share and hopefully just shout out to some of these people, 16 percent of our listeners come from outside the United States. And our second biggest country is Canada.
Boz: Yes, which if you are one of our Canadian listeners and you’re an educator, this came up in Guskey’s interview when they were talking about grade reporting reform and trying to look places that did it well, they had to go to Canada to find some. Like all of them that they found were in Canada. It is our second biggest area of listeners. So if you’re listening to this and you’re a Canadian educator, love to have you guys on. I’d love to really dive into some of the similarities and differences of the challenges that we face.
Welcome to the Grading Podcast, where we’ll take a critical lens to the methods of assessing students learning, from traditional grading to alternative methods of grading.
We’ll look at how grades impact our classrooms and our students success. I’m Robert Bosley, a high school math teacher, instructional coach, intervention specialist, and instructional designer in the Los Angeles Unified School District and with Cal State LA.
Sharona: And I’m Sharona Krinsky, a math instructor at Cal State Los Angeles, faculty coach, and instructional designer. Whether you work in higher ed or K 12, whatever your discipline is, whether you are a teacher, a coach, or an administrator, this podcast is for you. Each week you will get the practical, detailed information you need to be able to actually implement effective grading practices in your class and at your institution.
Boz: Hello and welcome back to the podcast. I’m Robert Bosley, one of your two co hosts and with me as always, Sharona Krinsky. How are you doing today, Sharona?
Sharona: I’m doing well. You know, my summer is very different than my year because I often switch largely to my other job. So we are in the middle of summer camp. We have some camp shows coming up. It’s a joy to work, and use my educator brain, but in a different setting. So instead of working with college math students, now I’m working with primarily kids and theater. And there’s a shocking amount of overlap. How about you?
Boz: Yeah. Well, you know because even though I live in California, I am originally from Oklahoma. I’m a proud Sooner. And my family and I, we always try to go back at least once a year during the summer, if not also during the holiday season. So yeah, we’re road tripping and driving around Oklahoma, Missouri, Texas. So depending on when you listen to this I might be in any one of those three states.
Sharona: Exactly. So tell me, how’s the weather been in Oklahoma this year?
Boz: You know, actually now that it’s summertime and it’s pretty hot and muggy, but it’s calmed down. Earlier this year, Oklahoma had a really bad tornado season. I mean, it was bad along a lot of places in the Midwest, but, yeah, it was a very active season for storm chasers in the state of Oklahoma.
Sharona: Yeah, that doesn’t sound fun. You know, people always tell me, Oh my gosh, you live in California. I could never live there. Earthquakes. And I’m like, you have tornadoes, ice storms, hurricanes every year. One year I lived in Ohio, 150 people died in an ice storm. I’m like, I’ll take my earthquakes that do a lot of damage once every 20 years. I’m good.
Boz: Hey, there was just a few years back that Oklahoma had wildfire blizzards, tornadoes, ice storms, and earthquake all in one week.
Sharona: Yeah. See, and we only get the wildfires and occasional flooding and the earthquake. So I’m good. Good. So this is a special episode.
Boz: This is a very special episode. This is episode 53, which for our non calendar people, what does that mean Sharona?
th of:Boz: It’s hard to believe. We started this, it seems so long ago, yet not so long ago.
Sharona: Exactly. I mean, for those of you just joining the podcast, the origin story is Bosley and I are sitting at breakfast one day and I said, I think we should do a podcast. And I really, I swear to God, I thought you were going to look at me and tell me I was insane. Because a, I am not to be ableist, but I may put a few too many things on my plate. And we, at the time we were working a lot and you said you thought it was a good idea. And then you took a sip of your drink. And do you remember what I said?
Boz: Something about the fact that you like to talk.
Sharona: I think I like to hear myself talking and you almost spit the drink across the thing. But here we are. So here we are. So we thought we’d take a few minutes and reflect. One of the principles of alternative grading is learning from feedback. And that feedback can be self reflection feedback.
Boz: Absolutely.
Sharona: So today we’re really going to be talking about what have we learned and what have been some of the successes and maybe some of the low lights as they call them.
Boz: Yeah. And just kind of looking back over this year long journey. And you know, like you said, taking a little bit of self reflection and just a moment to slow down and appreciate the fact that we’ve been doing this for a year.
Sharona: But I also wanted to use this as an example because one of the things that, in higher education, at least, that we do in the summer is we take a chance to reflect on the stuff that we taught and what we’re going to teach the next year. So I do kind of want to be conscious about this being an intentional reflection, taking the time to celebrate our successes and learn from our mistakes.
So where do you want to start? Do you want to start with some celebration or some learning?
Boz: I always like to start with the celebration.
Sharona: Okay. Why don’t you go first?
Boz: So looking back, I’m just curious. I know what my answer is, but looking back, what have been some of your, you know, top moments or our top episodes that you’ve just really enjoyed doing?
Sharona: So what I want to caveat this was saying, just like you don’t have favorite children. I don’t have favorite episodes. But I do have episodes in which I feel I learned a lot, I enjoyed it greatly. So maybe we’ll trade off. I’m not going to steal your thunder because I think you’re going to talk about your favorite. That is one of mine. I’m actually going to take the three times that we had Joe Zeccola on the podcast. So this was episodes 6, 13 and 39. It was my first opportunity to really speak with a high school teacher that was outside of STEM and doing this. So this was my chance to really begin to understand how alternative grading might work in a English classroom, how we might get students to buy in. And then the experience you and he had doing this as systemic change.
So that was definitely those three. I feel like I learned a lot. How about you?
Boz: Obviously the biggest highlight episode for me would be episode 33. When we got to interview the legend Dr. Thomas Guskey. And I know everyone’s always heard, you know, never meet your idols. Dr. Guskey is such a just down to earth, generally nice person that, this was not my first time interacting with him but having him on and just learning some of his very long history in this alt grading world and going back to when he was even working with Dr. Bloom and stuff. It was, it was a really fun episode. It was an educational episode and it was just a highlight to get to meet and sit down for over an hour and talk with just one of the titans in our world.
Sharona: I’d agree. And speaking of meeting your idols, another one for me is actually apparently one of the ones that so many in our community have taken the time to listen to, which is episode 4, Robert Talbert. By far the highest downloaded episode we have, but he’s also, although he’s not on the pod for this one, he’s the inspiration for episode 38: 20 small steps.
So I have now worked with Robert extensively for the past five years. And when I met him the first time, I had known him online, but just so thoughtful, so committed to the community. I just really, I really liked that one.
ave ever tried to do, back in:There was no way I was going to do it. And then you told me Robert Talbert was part of this, I’m like, Oh, nevermind. I’ll be glad to do it.
Sharona: Yeah. So you wouldn’t do it for me, but you do it for him. All right.
Boz: Yeah, the chance of getting to work with him, cause I had read his flipped classroom book. And that was when we designed our class for the slam project, that was part of it. We, we flipped it, you know, and that was part of our, our intentional design and part of our philosophy. So yeah, the chance to get to work with him. And then since the conference and the interviews, I’ve gotten to know him personally and another just extremely humble and down to earth guy that is just a great person and working with him and David Clark and their interactions with each other is so funny. Like those two guys together are great.
Sharona: And I want to go back for a moment to the episode you were talking about with Tom Guskey.
That was one, and I’ve said this before, I could listen to him speak probably for eight hours straight, but my favorite part of that episode was surprising you with the fact that I had booked him. That was absolutely one of my favorite moments of podcasting. And we had talked about reaching out to him.
So you knew that at some point we were going to reach out to him, but you had no idea that I had actually not only reached out to him, but actually booked him to come on the podcast. So that was one of my favorite moments.
Boz: I really didn’t think that we were big enough yet. I didn’t think that we’d been doing this long enough and we had enough cred yet to go up and try to invite one of these Titans and since then we’ve had some of the other really big names on this, but yeah, I didn’t think we were there yet.
I didn’t think there was any way that he was going to, to do this and, you know, knowing him, it shouldn’t be a surprise cause he is such a down to earth and just humble person. But yeah, you, you, when you let me know about it, that, that was a huge shocker and surprise. And if I remember right, it was also around my birthday.
Sharona: Yes, I think it was, I think it was. Speaking of titans, I really love talking to the sportscaster of alternative grading, Matt Townsley, on episodes 18 and 46. His books and talking to him, just so helpful. So helpful.
Boz: It was funny. I remember when we recorded that episode 18, I had read a couple of his, his books.
He was, he was at the conference before, but I think you knew a little bit more about him than I did at the time. And like, you want to talk about just a ball of energy. I mean, there’s a reason we call him the sportcaster of alternative grading.
He is so much fun to talk with and yeah, we’ve had him on twice now. The second time on episode 46, talking about his new book that he coauthored with a few other people called extinguishing the fire, which is one of my favorite books now. It has such a unique audience that it was targeting that if you are someone who is in a role of trying to push this forward, whether it’s as a trainer or as a, you know, policymaker in your school or your district, this is a must have book.
Yeah, that both of those episodes are a ton of fun. He’s just so energetic. It’s, it’s great having him on.
Sharona: So I think we have time for one more of our highlights each, and then we want to talk about some things we learned. So, last highlight for you, for now.
Boz: Oh, it’s so hard to choose. There’s a lot of them, but I think one of them, again, not because it’s one of my favorite, but because it was surprising how much fun doing the interview at the time was.
And that was, would be episode 42 with Dr. Teresa Gaines. Like that one. I mean, again, we’d had them on before, or not on the podcast, but in the grading conference, that interview that had to have been, next to Guskey’s, the quickest hour that I remember recording. I mean, I looked up on that one as we’re recording going, Oh, wow, we’re already at time and we’ve just gotten started. And I, I really do hope to have them on again. That’s one that I don’t think we really finished the interview, like with all the topics that we could have. So I I’m hoping to have them on again.
Sharona: Yeah. I’d say similarly to yours, one of the most surprising ones for me in terms of learning and enjoyability was episode 36 with Dr. Jeff Shinske. We had read his article that came out over a decade ago, but you never know where people have gone since then. And it just was such a joy and so many things that I learned. And this is something that I really enjoyed at the grading conference was listening to his keynote about content coverage.
And I need to think more about how this is going to play out in my own classes and how we can continue to move the conversation forward about content coverage.
Boz: And this is such a huge topic. I’m sure it’s a huge topic in most educational settings, but my experience as a high school math teacher, this is something that content coverage and oh, I don’t have time to do any of these other kinds of, whether it’s grading reform or other pedagogical reforms, because we got to get through this list of mile mile long of topics. So, that was a great keynote a great interview. So that was another one that I really enjoyed.
Sharona: Okay. Let’s move on to the things that we’ve learned this year. Both positive, to some degree, but also maybe some that we need to learn from as opposed to just learned.
Boz: I don’t know if it’s a learning or an aha, but, and I think I might be stealing a little bit of your thunder here, but I think one of my biggest aha moments, one of my things that I’ve learned was really on episode 32 with TJ Hitchman talking about that inverse relationship between student motivation and structure in your class. That the more motivated the students are, the less structure your grading architecture and your class just in general might need. Versus if you have, you know, students that are less motivated that you need a little bit more structure in place. So I think that was one of the, my biggest learning takeaways from any of the episodes, although there’s been lots of them, that’s the one that really sticks out in my mind. What about you?
Sharona: So the one that sticks out in my mind is something that happens during episode 31. And it’s something that I myself said. And in the moment I said it, I had an aha moment.
So I said that we needed to move away from time, place and manner, of an assignment or an assessment, giving it its reason. And what I mean by that is that I have been talking very much about, I hate, although I understand the construct, I don’t find formative versus summative informative to me in my teaching. Like that structure doesn’t help me because everything that I assess is formative until either the semester ends or the student succeeds, at which point it turns into summative.
But talking about time, place, and manner really made me think about gathering evidence and some of the unconscious constructs we have about the gathering of evidence. So we like to say in mathematics things like homework or exam. And yet now I have taken to having aha learning moments with my students literally while they’re taking an exam. So I have to take that into account as to whether or not that’s now evidence of their learning, or is it a moment for them to learn? So is it a formative thing that I’m adjusting on the fly or a summative thing?
Versus I can give a project that has to be done at home, because it’s outside the bounds of the time we have in class, and it can be valid evidence of learning. So I don’t like conflating the word homework with practice or succeed, preparation or actual demonstrating evidence of learning. Like having time, place and manner as the category for your work, for the stuff you do in and around your class, to me is not useful.
Because, again, even in stuff you do at home, you could be preparing, you could be participating, you could be practicing, or you could be providing evidence of learning. Like all of those things can happen at home, they can happen in class. So that was an aha moment where I said the words time, place, and manner, and I was like, oh, yes, that’s a construct I can use.
So I kind of had my own, aha moment.
Boz: And that one was great. Cause we were talking about deadlines when that came up. And I have, I don’t know if I’ve told you this or not, so, but I have used that in several of my small groups that I’ve, working with when it comes to either the question of homework or the question of deadlines or the question of what is considered gathering evidence and what’s considered practicing. And making those very clear distinctions in someone’s grading architecture when they’re setting up and redesigning their course. So I’ve, I’ve used that quite a bit. We always talk about stealing hubcaps. That is a hubcap that I have stolen many times over.
So yeah, I, I think that one was a great, kind of, like you said, aha moment of this is how we should be defining deadlines or whether or not we have deadlines on things. Because, you know, it came up in that episode because we were talking about, there are some things that you and I do have hard deadlines on that we don’t accept everything all the time because of the matter of work it is, you know, in specific, we were talking about if it’s meant to practice to get ready for, or to prep to get ready for a class, it doesn’t make sense to do it afterwards.
So yeah, my prep stuff does have deadlines. And that was something that I’ve talked with several of my groups that I work with, of high school educators, about thinking about their work. You know, what’s the purpose of it and does that purpose make sense to have a deadline or not?
Sharona: And the thing about re attempts without penalty, which is usually where this comes up, is where deadline flexibility comes up. We like our shortcuts. We like to say flexible due dates. Instead of saying what we really mean is students will have multiple opportunities to demonstrate evidence of learning on something. And maybe every one of those opportunities has deadlines that are not flexible. That’s a possibility.
It’s just that the idea is they have multiple chances at it, and those chances are spread out over a semester, so they’re not on an arbitrary time scale. So that by the end of the semester, students have had sufficient opportunities to show evidence of learning of the learning outcome. And when it comes to things like preparation, participation, and practice, to me, those are a specific learning outcome, which is learning how to learn.
And I don’t really care what they do to learn how to learn. Some students may learn better from learning that they need to prep, and some of them may need to mess that up and get that lower grade.
But what do I mean by that lower grade? Well, my learning how to learn standard is measured based on an accumulation of tasks. And so if they skip some of the tasks, they’ve got to do other tasks. They’ve got to get enough done. But there’s lots of ways to do that. And so, yeah, I definitely think that we’re learning, I’m learning how to articulate and describe the nuance here.
What about some other things we learned? I know we learned some things about podcasting.
Boz: And a lot of those were hard lessons learned. So we definitely we’ve always said and talked about how the learning process really is trying something, failing, getting feedback, trying something different.
That has definitely been the case with us in this year long journey on the podcast, hadn’t it?
Sharona: Well, it has. And you know, some things we are still trying to learn and haven’t figured out, like how to record both of us in the same physical room. I mean, we know how to do it. It just doesn’t work very well.
If you’re ever those future guests, which hopefully all of you will be future guests on the podcast, you should be aware that when we record and we say goodbye that goodbye is to the listeners. We need people to stay on our virtual recording studio because there’s some things that happen once we stop recording that need to happen.
We’ve learned that one the hard way as well.
Boz: In fact, if you go back and listen to episode six, this is when we learned that lesson. And if you really listen carefully for about the first 40 minutes compared to the last 20 minutes, you might hear the difference in sound quality. And that’s because we had logged off, and our guest, Joe Zeccola’s recording didn’t upload.
Now, luckily, our system does a backup but we had to end up using that backup for the last 20 minutes and the sound quality is nowhere near as good as the original recordings. So if you ever go back and listen to episode six, you probably, especially if you’ve got a good ear, I know Sharona, your ears are much better than mine when it comes to sound quality, probably because of your years of working with Encore and, and having being in musicals.
Sharona: I was just saying, no, it’s more 13 years of playing a piccolo. Because when you have a piccolo that is trying to play with the high trumpet and they’re clashing in tuning? The piccolo is the one that has to adjust. So I’d say that’s where my ear came from. Shout out to all you band geeks out there.
I think another thing that I am learning, just from this whole experience, is how necessary multiple ways of learning is. So one of the reasons we’re podcasting is because I desperately do not want to write a book. And that seems to be the other way that the word gets out about this stuff. But some people learn better from conversation.
And it’s a, having a recorded conversation, because conversations can be very ephemeral. You know, they can be very temporary. And once they’re gone, you only remember part of them. But having it recorded and having all of these incredible interviews, with the people we’ve gotten to talk to and being able to say, go back and look at episode 36, go back and look at episode 4, like, we’re trying to make this podcast, unlike say some of the news podcasts where you don’t really want to listen to the news from four years ago when we were in full shutdown. That’s, that’s not super fun.
But you can go back and most of these episodes, although we do mention, you know, our semesters or our travel, the content of the episode is relatively timeless and also not because we’re all continuing to learn how to do this. So it’s going to be interesting to see how that goes. Anything else you learned before we move on to the next segment?
Boz: I did learn, you know, over the year, just how much work goes into this.
So shout out to all the other podcasters. This, this is not just buying a couple of mics and recording and posting. So, yeah, I’ve definitely learned an appreciation for all the other podcasters out there that I I’ve enjoyed listening to over the years and in anyone that’s thinking about getting into it, it’s great.
It’s been very awarding, but it is also a lot more work than I realized.
rd of:Boz: Wow.
ive podcasts as of October of:Boz: Oh, wow.
Sharona: And we’ve looked at our podcast statistics and we’re in, I believe the top 20 percent of all podcasts in terms of
Boz: not, if you look at average weekly downloads, so the average amount of downloads an episode gets within the first seven days of dropping, we are somewhere between 20 to 25.
So that I think it was actually maybe the same article that you’re talking about or a similar one. At 25 I think it’s 117 or, and at 20 percent it’s 140. We’re usually in that range for the first week.
Sharona: It’s incredible. So I, well I was going to say I’m so grateful and that’s what I want to talk about next is the community. I’m so grateful to our community.
Boz: Yeah. I was going to say the same thing. I never would have thought until I read that, that we would be anywhere near there. Cause, you know, this is, somewhat of a, of a niche podcast. Like we’re talking to a specific group of people. So to know that this community is is large enough to do this and is being this supportive is extremely just flattering to me.
I’m sure it is to you as well. And it’s, it’s really been just breathtaking. The support we’ve been getting.
Sharona: Exactly. And I am really shocked at actually how big this community is. I mean, I know the grading conference has grown year over year over year, and that’s spectacular, but not everybody listens to podcasts.
So some of the statistics just to share and hopefully to shout out to some of these people. 16 percent of our listeners come from outside the United States. And our second biggest country is Canada.
Boz: Yes, which if you are one of our Canadian listeners and you’re an educator, this came up in Guskey’s interview about when they were talking about grade reporting reform.
And trying to look places that did it well, they had to go to Canada to find some. Like all of them that they found were in Canada. It is our second biggest area of listeners. So if you’re listening to this and you’re a Canadian educator, love to have you guys on, I’d love to really dive into some of the similarities and differences of the challenges that we face.
Cause I, and I’ll be honest, I don’t know a ton about the Canadian education system, so I’m not extremely familiar with how similar or different it is. So I really would, if you’re a Canadian educator, please reach out to us. We’d love to have you on.
Sharona: I completely concur. I also, however, want to shout out the 8 percent of our listeners that are outside of North America.
So we are now listened to in 40 countries around the world. And some of them, you might predict. The UK, Australia, some of the English speaking world. Also, the European Union, Germany, France, Brazil, I’m sorry, not Brazil, Germany, France, Spain, but then I did want to speak out about some of the other countries we see.
We have a cluster in Asia. We have North Korea, Japan, China, Taiwan, we have a group in Central and South America, Mexico, Costa Rica, Brazil. And then we have some from places that I am surprised. We have Saudi Arabia, we have Bosnia Herzegovina, Slovakia, Finland, Iceland, South Africa, North Macedonia, Kenya, New Zealand. So I’m not going to listen, list all of them. Cause again, there’s 40 and I don’t want to like list 39 of them and leave somebody out, but we would very much, I would very, very much like to talk to our listeners from outside North America. I don’t know if these are expats who are exporting American style schooling, or if this is something that’s more relevant or you do more of in your country, in your environment, in your culture. I think it would be incredible to have people on to talk about the similarities and differences with the United States educational system.
Boz: Yeah. In fact, the third largest area of our listeners are from Japan. Which again, I would, Absolutely love because I’ve had the experience before of meeting a couple of people from Japan that were educators. And, you know, them coming over in what’s called the Fulbright Foundation, coming over and visiting this country and basically taking a bit of time in this country in the education system to share notes and learn from each other’s differences and similarities.
So I would love absolutely love for any of the Asian countries, but I know Japan is our third largest country of listeners, so that would be really fun, I think.
Sharona: Well, let’s be more specific. You just want an excuse to visit Japan.
Boz: That’s, that’s true. Japan, Japan is my number one bucket list of places to go.
I am always been fascinated with Japanese culture. I am a martial artist. I’ve been doing martial arts almost my entire life. My oldest daughter, who’s now 17, we’ve been doing judo together since she was six. So yes, I, I would absolutely love to go have an excuse to go over there and record from Japan. That’s, that is true.
Sharona: So speaking of community, I think for me, looking ahead to the next year, that is my biggest goal is to continue to grow this community as a place of community to start to connect more people together. Having this podcast and being able to interview all of these incredible people, we’re already seeing places where we can bring people together and try to grow this work. I know that we’ve spoken to several people who are doing research projects. We want to try to get people doing research projects together. We want to continue to build communities of practice. This is very hard to do in isolation. And so having the support because change is hard and the educational system is big.
Boz: Yeah. So it’s big. And for a lot of reasons it is reluctant to change. I mean, I brought this up in a couple of episodes, but most people that are in education had to succeed at some level at the current status of education. Like the, the method of, of traditional grading and other pedagogies, we were the success stories. We got through it.
So trying to get that same group that was successful in one way to change that way is not easy work. And I agree with you. We’ve seen, through our interviews and through some of our other things, lots of little pockets of this going on. And yeah, that is something that I hope through this podcast and through some of the nonprofits that we’re both involved with, trying to bring some of these small pockets together to make bigger snowballs that maybe can really start picking up some steam.
Sharona: Well, and we also, when we spoke back on episode 44 about the impact of artificial intelligence, I still think that this is going to be cataclysmic and this next year, for myself, I am definitely on the AI learning curve and really reflecting on how AI is going to change not only our assessments, but probably also our standards. Our learning outcomes.
What are we teaching and how are we teaching it?
Boz: You know, I’m glad you brought that episode up. Looking back from the last year and forward into future, that’s one of those topics that I think we just scratched the surface. I think in the future we’re going to end up having several AI related episodes in our future.
So that’s out of all the different topics that we’ve talked about, that’s one that I really think we will continue to come back to. And like you said, you’re really trying to learn more about it. I’m really curious to see where that conversation, in general and how it interacts and relates with grading, how that conversation just matures and grows over the next chunk of time.
Sharona: I agree. I really do think it’s going to be cataclysmic and not in a bad way. I think there’s incredible opportunities that we as the alternative grading community are poised to be able to capture in ways that I think traditional grading is really, really going to struggle with.
Boz: Yeah.
Sharona: And I already see, I mean, I’m seeing reactionary things happening, that we did when calculus came along, when technology came along in mathematics, everyone reacted with banishing everything. I’m not sure that’s going to work with AI because our students have the power of choice in ways they didn’t use to. And I think they are going to, we’re seeing it. We are seeing so many students opting in, for example, to online courses that never would have pre pandemic.
And they are making the conscious choice to say, hey, my time is more valuable than sitting in a classroom. So I think we have some real opportunities, but I think we also have a student population with a lot more power. I think the power structures are shifting.
Boz: I would agree. And what’s both interesting and scary is it’s shifting in this direction that I have no idea where it’s going.
I really am sitting back looking at this going, I think I see a big change on the horizon, but I don’t know what that is. So I am curious and eager to keep this kind of line of conversation open.
Sharona: Unfortunately, there’s one direction I think it’s going to go that is very predictable, which is in a discriminatory way. Access to the technology and training on it is going to do a lot of the same separation work between people with access and people who don’t. And unfortunately that is likely to reinforce existing differences between different groups. So I’d like to be part of the group that is as on top of it as possible to try to address those gaps and not let them just run away from us.
Boz: Yeah, that’s true.
Sharona: How about you goals for this year, for the podcast from you?
Boz: You know, like I said, I, I really do want to continue to try to bring some of these small pockets of research that’s going on and bring them together. We’ve got a few hopeful interviews coming up that I’m really looking forward to.
And then just continuing to be in awe of just how big this community is. I do have one goal that I’m hoping that we can do this coming year that we weren’t able to do as much. This last year, and that is actually getting some of our guests on, we did have, which I’m still thrilled about, we did have one episode that’s that sparked enough of a of a flame that we got some of our listeners to when in particular call us out on it, which I was still very, very thankful for.
But yeah, I’m hoping that we end up with talking with some more of our actual audience and getting people that maybe aren’t the ones that are writing articles and that are writing books. Because that’s right now, the way we find most of our guests are either through that or through people they know that they’re recommending to us.
So I’d love to get more of Just every day in the trenches, educators that maybe are listening to this and this podcast and getting them on and getting that kind of, in the trench types of interviews and discussions.
Sharona: The thing is that one of the things that has not yet taken off, and I’m going to put a request into everybody who is listening is, one of the podcasts I listen to has what they call listener response calls.
So you can actually record a voice memo on your phone that, and you would just call in and say, this is a response to your guest on episode whatever, and share your thoughts. And you can actually attach that voice memo to the contact us form on our website. So if you go to thegradingpod.Com, there’s a contact us form that allows for attachments.
And we would love, for example, for this episode to get some listener response calls that said, Hey, have you thought of this goal? Or this was one of the things that you didn’t mention that I’ve really enjoyed this year. We’d really like to get that going in a much more interactive way. So if you would consider it, what you can do is you can start off your call telling us whether or not your name you’d like to be recognized, but so we don’t have to include your name if you don’t want, but say, you know, this is in response to episode whatever, and what was happening and we would love to play some of those voice response calls as part of the ending of each of our shows.
But in order to do that, we’ve got to get people to call in and
Boz: Go ahead. I was going to say, let me be clear about that. We’re not looking for just people that agree either. If something comes up in one of these episodes and you’re listening to it going, Oh no, that’s crazy, let us know. I don’t ever want to shy away from having healthy debates and discussions.
So if you’re listening to something and you’re like, Oh my God, that’s the craziest thing I’ve ever heard. We want to hear that too. We had the episode where we looked at a couple of articles that had some negativity about grading reform and standards based grading to be precise.
I would love to get some more of that kind of debate because, just that healthy open discussion is really what we need. And disagree with me if you want, that’s great. Come on and let’s have a real discussion about it. And when we part, will we have changed each other’s minds? Probably not. But that discussion is really needed in our community.
Sharona: So if I had a goal for this year, I would like listener response calls. But I would also like audio questions for us or for our guests. So you can, again, use a voice memo on the phone and attach it to the contact us form. But if there’s something that you tried that isn’t working and you want some advice or you want our thoughts on it, or you just want us to get a guest on who could answer something that might be more specific to your situation, please submit that too.
So if I could have my, if I could wave a magic wand and say, what is the next year going to hold? It’s launching those two segments, listener response calls to the things we say and listener questions, so that we can do that. You can also join the alternative grading Slack channel and there’s a link to that on our website.
And we can answer questions in there as well. We respond to direct messages in there. Maybe we’ll put a podcast channel on there at some point. I don’t think it’s up right now, but we would love to get that two way in engagement, especially the verbal one, like you guys listen to our voices. And as much as I love hearing myself talk, you may not. But we would love to hear your voices. So using that voice memo recording and attaching it. That would be probably one of my big goals for this year.
Boz: Yeah, I would, I would agree with those. And then I have one more on top of that. And that is, I want to hear from the primary educators, like that is a section that even though we say this podcast is for K through 12 and higher ed and, and beyond, we’ve not spent as much time talking about the primary grades. So,
Sharona: and to clarify, when you said primary educators, to me, I heard like principal investigators in my head, you mean primary school K through whatever.
Boz: I mean, yeah. K, K through five, K through six, whatever, whatever your system is set up as, but getting those early grades on, we’ve talked a little bit about some of them and some of the episodes. I know it came up It’s come up in, in episode 46 with, with Matt Townsley.
But I don’t think we’ve spent enough time focused on that. And that’s partly because you and I have very little to no experience as educators in those worlds.
Sharona: I had my aha moment on the podcast where I was like, Oh, crud. I was the bad parent because I was the one who was upset my kid wasn’t getting fives on a rubric scale on standards based report cards when my kids were little. Shout out to my kids’ elementary school teachers. I’m apologizing now.
Boz: But yeah, that would be my other goal.
Sharona: Yeah, I would agree. And you know, let’s, let’s just create a couple of other big goals. I’d like to do some live podcast recordings. Like if we’re You know, giving a talk somewhere or we want to have a few people in the audience. We kind of have to figure out how to make that work audio, which I’m confused because I seem to manage to do this with a 70 person cast and 32 wireless microphones, but I can’t manage it for a podcast. That’s just driving me crazy. So I’d like to do some live recording sessions. We’ll have to get that going.
Boz: That would be interesting. Yeah, that would be interesting.
Sharona: Maybe with a, maybe if we go somewhere, I know we’ve got some travel coming up to some conferences, maybe CMC South. If anyone’s going to CMC South, maybe we could set up a session and have a live audience there. That’d be kind of cool. Math Fest. Math Fest is coming up.
You won’t be there, but I will. Okay, so if y’all are going to math fest, I’m just going to create this on the spot. I’m going to take my recording equipment and see if we can get something going.
Boz: Okay.
Sharona: Cause I know there’s quite a few of you out there that are math fest. That would be cool. That would be cool. Maybe you’ll have to come join us, boz. So believe it or not, we did it again. We started an episode going, I don’t know if we’re going to be able to go long enough. And here we are 50 minutes in closing thoughts?
Boz: Closing thoughts. Just a really big thank you. This has been, the response, the numbers the support over this last year has just been incredible. It’s been flattering. So just a big thank you. And I hope you guys continue to listen as we start our second year at this.
Sharona: Yeah. And I would say that. I have been gratified not only by the people listening, but hearing that we’re impacting you. Like I’ve gone to some meetings and things and people are like, Oh my gosh, I listened to this episode or that episode and I learned something from it.
So that’s our goal. Our goal is to educate. That’s what we are. We’re educators and we can’t educate unless you tell us what you want, what you need and what you know. So thank you for coming along for the ride.
Boz: All right. And with that, we’ll see you guys next week.
Sharona: Please share your thoughts and comments about this episode by commenting on this episode’s page on our website, http://www.TheGradingPod.Com. Or you can share with us publicly on Twitter, Facebook, or Instagram. If you would like to suggest a future topic for the show or would like to be considered as a potential guest for the show, please use the contact us form on our website. The Grading Podcast is created and produced by Robert Bosley and Sharona Krinsky.
The full transcript of this episode is available on our website.
Boz: The views expressed here are those of the host and our guest. These views are not necessarily endorsed by the Cal State System or by the Los Angeles Unified School District.

Leave a Reply